Hall E, Parton R, Wardlaw A C
Division of Infection and Immunity, University of Glasgow, UK.
Vaccine. 1998 Oct;16(17):1595-603. doi: 10.1016/s0264-410x(98)80001-7.
Two acellular pertussis vaccines (SmithKline Beecham 3-component and Connaught 5-component), and a whole-cell pertussis vaccine (Evans), were similarly protective against paroxysmal coughing and leukocytosis in a coughing-rat model of pertussis. A two-dose immunization schedule was followed by sublethal intrabronchial challenge with Bordetella pertussis strain 18-323, encased in fine agarose beads, and the coughing monitored by sound-activated tape recorders. Pertussis toxoid by itself gave some protection against coughing, but lower than that afforded by the vaccines, despite inducing a higher serum anti-PT titre. The other component antigens, given individually, failed to protect against coughing although inducing antibodies. Immunization with the whole-cell and acellular vaccines and with their component antigens, as well as challenge with B. pertussis, caused significant elevation of total serum IgE antibodies. Antigen-specific IgG and IgA were detected in tracheobronchial washings from rats recovering from B. pertussis challenge, but vaccination prior to challenge had little influence on these antibody levels. The coughing-rat model of pertussis may be useful for the comparative testing of different formulations of pertussis vaccines before trials in human infants.
在百日咳咳嗽大鼠模型中,两种无细胞百日咳疫苗(史克必成3组分疫苗和康诺特5组分疫苗)以及一种全细胞百日咳疫苗(埃文斯疫苗)在预防阵发性咳嗽和白细胞增多方面具有相似的保护作用。采用两剂免疫程序,随后用包裹在精细琼脂糖珠中的百日咳博德特氏菌18 - 323株进行亚致死剂量的支气管内攻击,并通过声控磁带录音机监测咳嗽情况。百日咳毒素本身对咳嗽有一定的保护作用,但低于疫苗所提供的保护作用,尽管它能诱导更高的血清抗百日咳毒素滴度。其他单独给予的组分抗原尽管能诱导抗体产生,但未能预防咳嗽。用全细胞疫苗、无细胞疫苗及其组分抗原进行免疫,以及用百日咳博德特氏菌进行攻击,均导致血清总IgE抗体显著升高。在从百日咳博德特氏菌攻击中恢复的大鼠的气管支气管灌洗液中检测到了抗原特异性IgG和IgA,但在攻击前进行疫苗接种对这些抗体水平影响不大。百日咳咳嗽大鼠模型可能有助于在对人类婴儿进行试验之前,对不同配方的百日咳疫苗进行比较测试。