Guinard J X, Souchard A, Picot M, Rogeaux M, Sieffermann J M
Department of Food Science and Technology, University of California, USA.
Appetite. 1998 Aug;31(1):101-15. doi: 10.1006/appe.1998.0165.
The purpose of this study was to find which sensory characteristics are significant determinants of the thirst-quenching character of beer. The sensory attributes and thirst-quenching characteristics ("thirst quenching", "refreshing", "drinkability") of 18 beers were evaluated by a panel of 12 judges. The only significant positive determinants of the "thirst-quenching" character of the beers in the design were carbonation and bubble density. Significant negative determinants were foam, overall aroma and flavor, color, viscosity, malty, hoppy, burnt, bitterness, acidic, metallic, astringency and aftertaste. The same correlations (both in terms of direction and significance level) were observed between descriptive attributes and the "refreshing" and "drinkability" factors. A principal component analysis (PCA) of the mean ratings indicated that variability among beers was mostly along a thirst-quenching dimension (72% of the variance). Procrustes analysis performed on the individual ratings showed that, for one of the judges, the interpretation of the thirst-quenching concept differed from that shown by PCA for the overall panel.
本研究的目的是找出哪些感官特征是啤酒解渴特性的重要决定因素。由12名评委组成的小组对18种啤酒的感官属性和解渴特性(“解渴”、“清爽”、“可饮性”)进行了评估。在该设计中,啤酒“解渴”特性的唯一显著正向决定因素是碳酸化程度和气泡密度。显著的负向决定因素是泡沫、整体香气和风味、颜色、粘度、麦芽味、啤酒花味、焦味、苦味、酸味、金属味、涩味和余味。在描述性属性与“清爽”和“可饮性”因素之间观察到相同的相关性(在方向和显著性水平方面)。对平均评分进行的主成分分析(PCA)表明,啤酒之间的变异性主要沿着解渴维度(占方差的72%)。对个体评分进行的普罗克汝斯分析表明,对于其中一名评委来说,解渴概念的解释与PCA对整个小组所显示的不同。