Edston E, van Hage-Hamsten M
Institute of Forensic Medicine, University Hospital, Linköping, Sweden.
Forensic Sci Int. 1998 May 11;93(2-3):135-42. doi: 10.1016/s0379-0738(98)00040-1.
The reliability of measuring mast cell tryptase in post-mortem blood to diagnose anaphylactic deaths has been questioned because moderate elevation of tryptase can be seen also in control cases. Very high tryptase concentrations have been recorded even in a few control cases with known cause of death such as myocardial infarction or trauma. Aiming to compare findings we measured tryptase in 193 cases: 176 with known cause of death, 10 unexplained deaths and seven anaphylactic or anaphylactoid deaths (AADs). Using binary logistic regression we calculated the sensitivity and specificity of the tryptase test at different cut-off values and found 10 micrograms/l to be optimal, the sensitivity being 86% and the specificity 88%. Traumatic deaths (n = 23), sudden infant death syndrome (n = 40) or deaths after heroin-injection (n = 22) showed elevated tryptase values in 35%, 35% and 32%, respectively, and in 40% of the unexplained deaths (n = 10), which was higher than expected (12%). Heart blood tryptase level was elevated in 22% of the controls and femoral blood tryptase in 10%. No correlations were seen with age or post-mortem delay. It is concluded that tryptase measurements are useful in confirming death from AAD, and that blood should be sampled from the femoral vessels. In unexplained deaths tryptase measurement is a useful indicator, but the diagnosis is not to be based on the test alone.
通过检测死后血液中的肥大细胞类胰蛋白酶来诊断过敏性死亡的可靠性受到了质疑,因为在对照病例中也可观察到类胰蛋白酶的中度升高。即使在少数已知死因(如心肌梗死或外伤)的对照病例中,也记录到了非常高的类胰蛋白酶浓度。为了比较结果,我们检测了193例病例的类胰蛋白酶:176例已知死因,10例死因不明,7例过敏性或类过敏性死亡(AAD)。使用二元逻辑回归,我们计算了不同临界值下类胰蛋白酶检测的敏感性和特异性,发现10微克/升为最佳临界值,敏感性为86%,特异性为88%。创伤性死亡(n = 23)、婴儿猝死综合征(n = 40)或海洛因注射后死亡(n = 22)的类胰蛋白酶值升高的比例分别为35%、35%和32%,在40%的死因不明病例(n = 10)中也升高,高于预期的12%。对照组中心脏血液类胰蛋白酶水平升高的占22%,股静脉血液类胰蛋白酶升高的占10%。未发现与年龄或死后间隔时间存在相关性。结论是,类胰蛋白酶检测有助于确诊AAD导致的死亡,且应从股静脉采集血液样本。在死因不明的病例中,类胰蛋白酶检测是一个有用的指标,但诊断不能仅基于该检测结果。