Bozzao A, Floris R, Villani A, Varrucciu V, Baviera M E, Simonetti G
Istituto di Radiologia, Università degli Studi Tor Vergata, Ospedale Sant'Eugenio, Roma.
Radiol Med. 1998 Jun;95(6):577-82.
Some clinical trials (NASCET, ECTS) have assessed that carotid endarterectomy is protective against stroke in patients with asymptomatic severe carotid stenosis. In order to decrease costs and risks, new diagnostic tools have been developed, such as Magnetic Resonance Angiography (MRA), duplex Ultrasound (US) and more recently Spiral Computed Tomography Angiography (CTA). CTA provides excellent 3D angiography images of the extracranial vessels using a volume rendering technique. This study was aimed at prospectively evaluating the accuracy of CTA in the diagnosis of carotid bifurcation. The circle of Willis was also studied during the same bolus injection. DSA was used as the gold standard technique. Surgery was also used for comparison.
Spiral CTA and DSA were performed in 106 carotid bifurcations. DSA was performed in all patients within 48-72 hours of CTA. The degree of internal carotid stenosis was evaluated according to NASCET criteria. Degree of stenosis, presence of calcifications, ulcerations and tandem lesions were reviewed by two different neuroradiologists blinded to each other and to the results of the other technique. In 19 cases the size of residual lumen of the ICA was surgically evaluated and correlated with CTA.
There was an overall correlation between CTA and DSA in 94% of cases. Our data are in agreement with the results of the current literature. CT angiograms overrated by one category 6 cases (25%) of mild and one of moderate stenosis (7.14%). Calcifications were seen on spiral CT angiography in 69 (65.09%) carotid bifurcations while DSA detected the presence in 31 (29.24%). Ulcerations were missed by CTA in 3 cases. Five (4.71%) tandem lesions were visualized by DSA distal to bifurcation: 2 (1.88%) were also diagnosed by CTA. The patency of the circle of Willis was assessed in all cases. In 19 cases, the size of ICA stenosis evaluated at surgery was comparable with CTA findings.
In conclusion CTA offers an outstanding alternative to catheter angiography in the evaluation of stenosis-occlusion of the carotid bifurcation. The intracranial circulation can be easily assessed by CTA as well, which allows the study of tandem lesions and of the circle of Willis.
一些临床试验(北美症状性颈动脉内膜切除术试验、欧洲颈动脉外科试验)评估了颈动脉内膜切除术对无症状严重颈动脉狭窄患者预防中风的作用。为了降低成本和风险,已开发出新的诊断工具,如磁共振血管造影(MRA)、双功超声(US)以及最近的螺旋计算机断层血管造影(CTA)。CTA使用容积再现技术可提供颅外血管出色的三维血管造影图像。本研究旨在前瞻性评估CTA在诊断颈动脉分叉方面的准确性。在同一团注注射期间还对 Willis 环进行了研究。数字减影血管造影(DSA)被用作金标准技术。手术结果也用于比较。
对106个颈动脉分叉进行了螺旋CTA和DSA检查。所有患者在CTA检查后的48 - 72小时内进行DSA检查。根据北美症状性颈动脉内膜切除术试验标准评估颈内动脉狭窄程度。由两位互不了解对方情况且对另一项技术结果不知情的神经放射科医生对狭窄程度、钙化、溃疡和串联病变情况进行评估。在19例患者中,通过手术评估了颈内动脉残余管腔大小,并与CTA结果进行关联。
在94%的病例中,CTA与DSA总体上具有相关性。我们的数据与当前文献结果一致。CT血管造影将6例(25%)轻度狭窄和1例中度狭窄(7.14%)高估了一个等级。在69个(65.09%)颈动脉分叉的螺旋CT血管造影中可见钙化,而DSA检测到钙化的有31个(29.24%)。CTA漏诊了3例溃疡。DSA在分叉远端发现了5个(4.71%)串联病变:CTA也诊断出其中2个(1.88%)。对所有病例的Willis环通畅情况进行了评估。在19例患者中,手术评估的颈内动脉狭窄大小与CTA结果相当。
总之,在评估颈动脉分叉的狭窄 - 闭塞情况时,CTA为导管血管造影提供了出色的替代方法。CTA也能够轻松评估颅内循环,从而可以对串联病变和Willis环进行研究。