Jerant A F, DeGaetano J S, Epperly T D, Hannapel A C, Miller D R, Lloyd A J
Department of Family and Community Medicine, Dwight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon, Georgia, USA.
J Am Board Fam Pract. 1998 Jul-Aug;11(4):296-306. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.11.4.296.
Varicella infection causes substantial morbidity in young adults. Most military basic trainees are 18 to 21 years old, yet the Army has no varicella vaccination policy. We therefore determined varicella susceptibility in a population of Army basic trainees, examined variables that might predict antibody status, and developed a vaccination strategies model.
Fifteen-hundred ninety-five trainees completed a demographic and historical questionnaire. Varicella antibody status was determined on 1201 volunteers. These data plus information from the literature were used to construct a decision tree of vaccination strategies that was applied to the total population of Army basic trainees in 1995 (n = 65,298).
Fifty (4.2 percent) of 1201 soldiers were antibody negative. Trainees who lived with no or 1 sibling while growing up were most likely to be seronegative (P < 0.01). The positive predictive value of a history of varicella was 98.5 percent, whereas the negative predictive value of a negative history of varicella was 23 percent. In the vaccination strategies model, serologically testing soldiers with a negative history of varicella and vaccinating those without protective antibodies was the most cost-effective approach.
In young adults a positive varicella history accurately predicts immunity, but verification of a negative history with antibody testing is recommended before vaccination.
水痘感染在年轻成年人中会导致相当高的发病率。大多数陆军基础训练学员年龄在18至21岁之间,但陆军没有水痘疫苗接种政策。因此,我们确定了陆军基础训练学员群体中的水痘易感性,研究了可能预测抗体状态的变量,并建立了一个疫苗接种策略模型。
1595名学员完成了一份人口统计学和病史调查问卷。对1201名志愿者进行了水痘抗体状态检测。这些数据以及来自文献的信息被用于构建一个疫苗接种策略决策树,并应用于1995年陆军基础训练学员的总群体(n = 65298)。
1201名士兵中有50名(4.2%)抗体呈阴性。成长过程中没有兄弟姐妹或只有1个兄弟姐妹的学员最有可能血清学阴性(P < 0.01)。水痘病史的阳性预测值为98.5%,而水痘病史阴性的阴性预测值为23%。在疫苗接种策略模型中,对水痘病史阴性的士兵进行血清学检测,并对没有保护性抗体的士兵进行接种是最具成本效益的方法。
在年轻成年人中,水痘病史阳性能准确预测免疫力,但在接种疫苗前建议通过抗体检测来核实病史阴性情况。