Ayotte P, Lévesque B, Gauvin D, McGregor R G, Martel R, Gingras S, Walker W B, Létourneau E G
Québec Public Health Centre, Beauport, Canada.
Health Phys. 1998 Sep;75(3):297-302. doi: 10.1097/00004032-199809000-00009.
The objective of this study was to assess the lung cancer risk resulting from indoor radon exposure in the province of Quebec, Canada, and to evaluate the efficacy of mitigation measures to reduce this exposure. Concentrations of radon were determined in a representative sample of houses, and the corresponding lung cancer risk estimates were generated using the BEIR IV model, taking into account smoking, residential mobility, and regional variations in radon concentrations. Mean (geometric) radon concentrations in basements (n = 418) and on first floors (n = 319) were, respectively, 34.4 (95% CI-30.6 to 38.8) and 16.5 Bq m(-3) (14.2 to 19.3). A total of 109 deaths from lung cancer are predicted to occur as a result of this exposure in a cohort of 60,000 people. Detecting all residences with high radon concentrations (equal to or above 200 Bq m(-3)) and implementing mitigation measures in each of them would reduce by 4 the number of lung cancer deaths attributable to indoor radon exposure. A reduction of 0.05% in the prevalence of smoking would prevent as many deaths from lung cancer as would radon mitigation. From a public health perspective, in order to reduce mortality from lung cancer, most efforts should be focused on smoking, not on the relatively minor and hardly preventable population risk arising from household radon exposure.
本研究的目的是评估加拿大魁北克省室内氡暴露导致的肺癌风险,并评估降低这种暴露的缓解措施的效果。在具有代表性的房屋样本中测定了氡浓度,并使用BEIR IV模型生成了相应的肺癌风险估计值,同时考虑了吸烟、居住流动性以及氡浓度的区域差异。地下室(n = 418)和一楼(n = 319)的平均(几何)氡浓度分别为34.4(95%可信区间为30.6至38.8)和16.5 Bq m(-3)(14.2至19.3)。预计在60,000人的队列中,由于这种暴露将导致总共109例肺癌死亡。检测出所有氡浓度高(等于或高于200 Bq m(-3))的住宅并在每处实施缓解措施,可将归因于室内氡暴露的肺癌死亡人数减少4倍。吸烟率降低0.05%预防的肺癌死亡人数与氡缓解措施相同。从公共卫生角度来看,为了降低肺癌死亡率,大多数努力应集中在吸烟上,而不是家庭氡暴露所带来的相对较小且难以预防的人群风险上。