Benhamou D, Thorin D, Brichant J F, Dailland P, Milon D, Schneider M
Department of Anesthesia, Université Paris-Sud, Hôpital Antoine-Béclère, Clamart, France.
Anesth Analg. 1998 Sep;87(3):609-13. doi: 10.1097/00000539-199809000-00022.
Seventy-eight pregnant women at term, scheduled for elective cesarean section, were enrolled in this multicenter trial to compare the analgesic efficacy and side effect profile of a spinal block with hyperbaric bupivacaine alone (Group B) or combined with 75 microg of clonidine (Group BC) or with clonidine 75 microg and fentanyl 12.5 microg (Group BCF). Intraoperatively, clonidine increased the spread of the sensory block and decreased pain (pain scores 23+/-7 mm vs 17+/-6 and 2+/-1 mm for Group B versus Groups BC and BCF; P < 0.05) and analgesic supplementation. This improved analgesia was best with the clonidine-fentanyl combination (Group BC versus Group BCF; P < 0.05). Postoperative analgesia was prolonged only in Group BCF (215+/-79 min vs 137+/-35 and 183+/-80 min for Group BCF versus Groups B and BC; P < 0.05). Blood pressure and heart rate changes were not significantly different among groups, whereas sedation and pruritus were significantly more frequent in Group BCF. Nausea and vomiting were decreased in Groups BC and BCF. Apgar scores and umbilical artery blood pH were not different among groups. We conclude that adding a small dose of intrathecal clonidine to bupivacaine increases the quality of intraoperative analgesia and decreases pain during cesarean section. Combining clonidine with fentanyl further improved analgesia.
In this study, we demonstrate improved intraoperative spinal analgesia by adding 75 microg of clonidine to bupivacaine; side effects were not increased. The combination of clonidine and fentanyl further improved analgesia but moderately increased sedation and pruritus.
78名足月孕妇计划行择期剖宫产,被纳入这项多中心试验,以比较单纯布比卡因重比重液蛛网膜下腔阻滞(B组)、布比卡因重比重液联合75微克可乐定(BC组)或布比卡因重比重液联合75微克可乐定和12.5微克芬太尼(BCF组)的镇痛效果和副作用情况。术中,可乐定增加了感觉阻滞范围,减轻了疼痛(B组疼痛评分23±7毫米,BC组和BCF组分别为17±6毫米和2±1毫米;P<0.05),减少了镇痛补充用药。可乐定与芬太尼联合使用时镇痛效果最佳(BC组与BCF组比较;P<0.05)。仅BCF组术后镇痛时间延长(BCF组为215±79分钟,B组和BC组分别为137±35分钟和183±80分钟;P<0.05)。各组间血压和心率变化无显著差异,而BCF组镇静和瘙痒更为常见。BC组和BCF组恶心和呕吐减少。各组间阿氏评分和脐动脉血pH值无差异。我们得出结论,布比卡因中加入小剂量鞘内可乐定可提高剖宫产术中镇痛质量并减轻疼痛。可乐定与芬太尼联合使用可进一步改善镇痛效果。
在本研究中,我们证明布比卡因中加入75微克可乐定可改善术中蛛网膜下腔镇痛,且未增加副作用。可乐定与芬太尼联合使用可进一步改善镇痛效果,但适度增加了镇静和瘙痒。