Kulkarni J, Adams J, Thomas E, Silman A
Department of Rehabilitation, University Hospital of South Manchester, UK.
Clin Rehabil. 1998 Aug;12(4):348-53. doi: 10.1191/026921598672393611.
To investigate the association between amputation, osteoarthritis and osteopenia in male war veterans with major lower limb amputations. Specific questions were to determine whether lower limb amputees following trauma are at subsequent risk of developing osteoarthritis (OA) and osteoporosis of the hip on both the amputated and nonamputated sides.
Retrospective cohort study in British Male Second World War veterans with major unilateral lower limb amputations.
Seventy-five male Second World War veterans with major lower limb amputations known to be alive were invited to participate from a subregional rehabilitation centre. After exclusions, 44 agreed to attend for examination and radiological screening.
The presence of hip OA was determined from a single anterior posterior pelvic X-ray using two approaches: minimum joint space and the Kellgren and Lawrence (K&L) scoring system. Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured by a dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) scan and prosthetic rehabilitation outcome measures were recorded.
Twenty-seven (61%) hips on the amputated side and 10 (23%) on the nonamputated side were positive for OA (based on Kellgren and Lawrence grade of >2). Using a minimum joint space threshold of below 2.5 mm, 24 (55%) hips on the amputation side and 8 (18%) on the nonamputated side were also positive for OA. There was a threefold increased risk of OA for those with above-knee compared to a below-knee amputation. By contrast, from published general population surveys only 4 (11%) cases of hip OA would have been expected on both the amputated and nonamputated hips. There was a significant decrease in femoral neck BMD in the amputated side (p <0.0001) and significantly lower BMD in above-knee amputees than in below-knee amputees (p = 0.0027) as compared to normal age- and sex-matched population.
Male war veterans with unilateral major lower limb amputations develop significantly more osteoarthritis of the hip than expected on both ipsi- and contralateral sides. Amputation was also associated with loss of bone density. Above-knee amputees develop significantly more hip osteoarthritis and osteopenia of greater severity in the amputated side than below-knee amputees.
调查接受主要下肢截肢手术的男性退伍军人中截肢、骨关节炎和骨质减少之间的关联。具体问题是确定创伤后下肢截肢者在截肢侧和非截肢侧随后发生骨关节炎(OA)和髋部骨质疏松的风险。
对接受主要单侧下肢截肢手术的英国男性二战退伍军人进行回顾性队列研究。
来自一个分区康复中心的75名已知在世的接受主要下肢截肢手术的男性二战退伍军人被邀请参与研究。排除部分人员后,44人同意参加检查和放射学筛查。
使用两种方法通过单次前后位骨盆X光片确定髋部OA的存在:最小关节间隙以及凯尔格伦和劳伦斯(K&L)评分系统。通过双能X线吸收法(DXA)扫描测量骨密度(BMD),并记录假体康复结局指标。
截肢侧27个髋部(61%)和非截肢侧10个髋部(23%)OA呈阳性(基于凯尔格伦和劳伦斯分级>2)。使用2.5毫米以下的最小关节间隙阈值时,截肢侧24个髋部(55%)和非截肢侧8个髋部(18%)OA也呈阳性。与膝下截肢者相比,膝上截肢者发生OA的风险增加了两倍。相比之下,根据已发表的一般人群调查,预计截肢侧和非截肢侧髋部仅有4例(11%)髋部OA。与年龄和性别匹配的正常人群相比,截肢侧股骨颈BMD显著降低(p<0.0001),膝上截肢者的BMD显著低于膝下截肢者(p = 0.0027)。
单侧主要下肢截肢的男性退伍军人在同侧和对侧发生髋部骨关节炎的情况明显多于预期。截肢还与骨密度降低有关。与膝下截肢者相比,膝上截肢者在截肢侧发生的髋部骨关节炎和骨质减少更为严重。