Spaid W M
School of Social Work, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah 84602-4472, USA.
J Case Manag. 1998 Spring;7(1):24-30.
Two research questions were addressed in this study of 57 older adult outpatients diagnosed with schizophrenia and 37 older adults attending a senior citizen's center with no significant medical or psychological problems. The research questions were: (a) Are there gender-based differences in giving and receiving expressive and instrumental social supports for chronically mentally ill patients? (b) Do chronically mentally ill elderly patients differ from older adults without chronic mental illness in giving and receiving expressive and instrumental social supports? Based on a two-factor multi variate analysis of variance, women, with or without diagnosis of chronic mental illness, were more likely than were men to provide emotionally close social contacts with others, as well as to give advice to and receive advice from others. However, there were no differences in giving or receiving instrumental or expressive social supports based on whether or not the respondent was receiving outpatient psychiatric services for a chronic mental illness. In view of this, the possibility that the mentally ill have more to offer in relationships than is generally assumed is discussed. Suggestions for future research and implications for case managers also are discussed.
本研究针对57名被诊断为精神分裂症的老年门诊患者以及37名在老年中心就诊且无重大医学或心理问题的老年人展开。研究探讨了两个问题:(a)对于慢性精神病患者,在给予和接受表达性及工具性社会支持方面是否存在基于性别的差异?(b)慢性精神病老年患者与无慢性精神疾病的老年人在给予和接受表达性及工具性社会支持方面是否存在差异?基于双因素多变量方差分析,无论是否被诊断为慢性精神疾病,女性比男性更有可能与他人建立情感亲密的社会联系,也更有可能向他人提供建议并接受他人的建议。然而,根据受访者是否因慢性精神疾病接受门诊精神科服务,在给予或接受工具性或表达性社会支持方面并无差异。鉴于此,文中讨论了精神病患者在人际关系中可能比一般认为的更有贡献这一可能性。还讨论了对未来研究的建议以及对个案管理人员的启示。