Hamadeh G N, Adib S M
Department of Family Medicine, American University of Beirut, Lebanon.
Soc Sci Med. 1998 Nov;47(9):1289-94. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(98)00203-2.
Truthful disclosure of cancer diagnosis is still uncommon in some cultures. In Lebanon, legislation is permissive of non-disclosure. Physicians choose the recourse most agreeable to them. This study's goal was to determine the proportion of Lebanese physicians who choose truthful diagnosis disclosure to cancer patients and to identify factors affecting their choice. A survey of a random sample of Lebanese physicians was conducted to determine the proportion of those who prefer truthful diagnosis disclosure to cancer patients and to identify factors affecting that choice. The survey involved 268 participants representing 10% of all physicians practicing in specialties with potential contact with cancer cases in the Greater Beirut area. It was completed by 212 (79%), of whom 47% would usually tell the patient about cancer. Disclosure preference was not associated with gender, location of medical training, rate of patient contact or teaching activities. It was associated with longer clinical practice and with specialties outside primary care. Most participants were open to changing their policies and considered the patient's desire to know, compliance with treatment and the patient's profession as a physician as most influencing in their choice of disclosure. Exploring the Lebanese public predicament regarding disclosure seems necessary.
在某些文化中,如实告知癌症诊断结果的情况仍然并不常见。在黎巴嫩,法律允许不告知患者。医生会选择他们认为最合适的做法。本研究的目的是确定选择向癌症患者如实告知诊断结果的黎巴嫩医生的比例,并找出影响他们选择的因素。对黎巴嫩医生的随机样本进行了一项调查,以确定那些倾向于向癌症患者如实告知诊断结果的医生比例,并找出影响这一选择的因素。该调查涉及268名参与者,占大贝鲁特地区所有可能接触癌症病例专业的执业医生的10%。212人(79%)完成了调查,其中47%的人通常会告知患者患癌情况。是否倾向于如实告知与性别、医学培训地点、患者接触率或教学活动无关。它与较长的临床实践经验以及初级保健以外的专业有关。大多数参与者愿意改变他们的政策,并认为患者了解病情的愿望、对治疗的依从性以及患者作为医生的职业对他们选择如实告知的影响最大。探索黎巴嫩公众在信息披露方面的困境似乎很有必要。