O'Toole A J, Edelman S, Bülthoff H H
School of Human Development GR4.1, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson 75083-0688, USA.
Vision Res. 1998 Aug;38(15-16):2351-63. doi: 10.1016/s0042-6989(98)00042-x.
Individual faces vary considerably in both the quality and quantity of the information they contain for recognition and for viewpoint generalization. In the present study, we assessed the typicality, recognizability, and viewpoint generalizability of individual faces using data from both human observers and from a computational model of face recognition across viewpoint change. The two-stage computational model incorporated a viewpoint alignment operation and a recognition-by-interpolation operation. An interesting aspect of this particular model is that the effects of typicality it predicts at the alignment and recognition stages dissociate, such that face typicality is beneficial for the success of the alignment process, but is adverse for the success of the recognition process. We applied a factor analysis to the covariance data for the human- and model-derived face measures across the different viewpoints and found two axes that appeared consistently across all viewpoints. Projection scores for individual faces on these axes (i.e. the extent to which a face's 'performance profile' matched the pattern of human- and model-derived scores on that axis), correlated across viewpoint changes to a much higher degree than did the raw recognizability scores of the faces. These results suggest that the stimulus information captured in the model measures may underlie distinct and dissociable aspects of the recognizability of individual faces across viewpoint change.
个体面部在用于识别和视角泛化的信息质量和数量上有很大差异。在本研究中,我们使用来自人类观察者和跨视角变化的人脸识别计算模型的数据,评估了个体面部的典型性、可识别性和视角泛化性。这个两阶段的计算模型包含一个视角对齐操作和一个插值识别操作。这个特定模型的一个有趣之处在于,它在对齐和识别阶段预测的典型性效应是分离的,即面部典型性有利于对齐过程的成功,但对识别过程的成功是不利的。我们对不同视角下人类和模型得出的面部测量协方差数据进行了因子分析,发现了在所有视角下都一致出现的两个轴。个体面部在这些轴上的投影分数(即一张脸的“表现概况”与该轴上人类和模型得出的分数模式的匹配程度),在视角变化中相互关联的程度比面部的原始可识别性分数高得多。这些结果表明,模型测量中捕获的刺激信息可能是个体面部在视角变化中可识别性的不同且可分离方面的基础。