Reimold S C, Maisel W H, Antman E M
Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Am J Cardiol. 1998 Oct 16;82(8A):66N-71N. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9149(98)00587-6.
The purpose of this study was to determine propafenone's effectiveness in terminating and suppressing supraventricular arrhythmias using meta-analytic techniques. Published abstracts and manuscripts with these goals were selected and data abstracted on conversion and maintenance of sinus rhythm. Data were pooled using standard meta-analytic techniques and analyzed according to observation times, trial design (randomized versus nonrandomized), and route of drug administration. Propafenone successfully terminated 83.8% (95% confidence interval 78.1-89.7%) of supraventricular tachycardias. For supraventricular tachycardias, the proportion of patients remaining in sinus rhythm without recurrent arrhythmia was 64.6% (58.1-71.1%) at 1 year. The likelihood of converting a paroxysm of atrial fibrillation (AF) increased over time, with 76.1% (72.8-79.4%) of patients in sinus rhythm 24 hours after initiation of therapy. Patients receiving intravenous therapy were more likely to convert to sinus rhythm in the first 4 hours after drug administration. The treatment benefit of propafenone versus placebo in converting sinus rhythm was greatest in the first 8 hours after treatment (treatment benefit of 31.5% [24.5-38.5%] at 4 hours and 32.9% [24.3-41.5%] at 8 hours, p <0.01). This treatment benefit decreased to 1 1.0% (-0.6-22.4%) after 24 hours. Propafenone was effective in suppressing recurrences of AF in 55.4% (51.3-59.7%) at 6 months and 56.8% (52.3-61.3%) at 12 months. Thus, propafenone is effective in terminating supraventricular tachycardias and AF in the vast majority of patients. Suppression of arrhythmia recurrences is feasible in most patients, although its effectiveness decreases over time.
本研究的目的是采用荟萃分析技术确定普罗帕酮在终止和抑制室上性心律失常方面的有效性。选取了具有这些目标的已发表摘要和手稿,并提取了关于窦性心律转复和维持的数据。使用标准荟萃分析技术汇总数据,并根据观察时间、试验设计(随机与非随机)以及药物给药途径进行分析。普罗帕酮成功终止了83.8%(95%置信区间78.1 - 89.7%)的室上性心动过速。对于室上性心动过速,1年后窦性心律维持且无心律失常复发的患者比例为64.6%(58.1 - 71.1%)。房颤(AF)发作转复的可能性随时间增加,治疗开始后24小时,76.1%(72.8 - 79.4%)的患者为窦性心律。接受静脉治疗的患者在给药后的前4小时更有可能转复为窦性心律。普罗帕酮与安慰剂相比,在治疗后最初8小时转复窦性心律的治疗获益最大(4小时时治疗获益为31.5% [24.5 - 38.5%],8小时时为32.9% [24.3 - 41.5%],p<0.01)。24小时后,这种治疗获益降至11.0%( - 0.6 - 22.4%)。普罗帕酮在6个月时对抑制房颤复发有效率为55.4%(51.3 - 59.7%),12个月时为56.8%(52.3 - 61.3%)。因此,普罗帕酮在绝大多数患者中可有效终止室上性心动过速和房颤。在大多数患者中抑制心律失常复发是可行的,尽管其有效性会随时间降低。