Bernhardt T M, Rapp-Bernhardt U, Fessel A, Ludwig K, Reichel G, Grote R
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Otto-von-Guericke-University, University Hospital, Magdeburg, Germany.
Br J Radiol. 1998 Aug;71(848):846-51. doi: 10.1259/bjr.71.848.9828797.
Paranasal sinuses of 52 patients with sinusitis, tumours or fibrous dysplasia were scanned. Axially acquired spiral data were obtained and reconstructed coronally. Four radiologists compared the two sets of images. They evaluated the diagnostic quality for visualization of the ostiomeatal unit, infundibulum, infraorbital canal, inflammatory disease, fine osseous lamellae and presence of amalgam or step artefacts. Two test phantoms were scanned for both techniques and lens dose was measured. Statistical significant differences in the diagnostic quality of the representation of the fine osseous structures in the paranasal sinuses, attributable to step artefacts were found in the coronally reconstructed images (p < 0.001). However, there was no amalgam and almost no motion artefacts in the reconstructed images. Interobserver correlation was r = 0.953 versus 0.956 for inflammatory disease, r = 0.816 versus 0.852 for artefacts, and r = 0.596 versus 0.547 for fine osseous lamellae in coronally acquired or axially acquired and reconstructed images, respectively. Lens dose was measured between 11.8 mGy and 13.8 mGy for axially acquired and reconstructed images. The advantage of axially acquired, coronally reconstructed images is the absence of artefacts attributable to amalgam and fewer motion artefacts. Axially acquired, coronally reconstructed images are inferior to coronal helical CT images, because of step artefacts, when it comes to evaluating the resolution of fine osseous structures. Nevertheless, reconstructed images are suitable as a investigatory procedure for patients with inflammatory disease who cannot maintain the prone position.
对52例患有鼻窦炎、肿瘤或骨纤维发育不良的患者的鼻窦进行了扫描。获取了轴向采集的螺旋数据并进行了冠状面重建。四位放射科医生对两组图像进行了比较。他们评估了用于观察窦口鼻道复合体、漏斗、眶下管、炎症性疾病、精细骨板以及汞合金或阶梯状伪影的诊断质量。对两种技术都扫描了两个测试体模并测量了晶状体剂量。在冠状面重建图像中发现,由于阶梯状伪影,鼻窦中精细骨结构显示的诊断质量存在统计学显著差异(p < 0.001)。然而,重建图像中没有汞合金伪影且几乎没有运动伪影。对于冠状面采集或轴向采集并重建的图像,观察者间的相关性分别为:炎症性疾病方面,r = 0.953对0.956;伪影方面,r = 0.816对0.852;精细骨板方面,r = 0.596对0.547。轴向采集并重建图像的晶状体剂量在11.8 mGy至13.8 mGy之间。轴向采集、冠状面重建图像的优点是不存在汞合金引起的伪影且运动伪影较少。在评估精细骨结构的分辨率时,由于阶梯状伪影,轴向采集、冠状面重建图像不如冠状面螺旋CT图像。尽管如此,重建图像对于不能保持俯卧位的炎症性疾病患者而言,仍适合作为一种检查方法。