Phillips W T, Kiratli B J, Sarkarati M, Weraarchakul G, Myers J, Franklin B A, Parkash I, Froelicher V
Department of Physical Education, Arizona State University, Tempe, USA.
Curr Probl Cardiol. 1998 Nov;23(11):641-716. doi: 10.1016/s0146-2806(98)80003-0.
The use of various FES protocols to encourage increases in physical activity and to augment physical fitness and reduce heart disease risk is a relatively new, but growing field of investigation. The evidence so far supports its use in improving potential health benefits for patients with SCI. Such benefits may include more efficient and safer cardiac function; greater stimulus for metabolic, cardiovascular, and pulmonary training adaptations; and greater stimulus for skeletal muscle training adaptations. In addition, the availability of relatively inexpensive commercial FES units to elicit muscular contractions, the ease of use of gel-less, reusable electrodes, and the increasing popularity of home and commercial upper body exercise equipment mean that such benefits are likely to be more accessible to the SCI population through increased convenience and decreased cost. The US Department of Health and Human Services has identified those with SCI as a "special population" whose health problems are accentuated, and so need to be specifically addressed. FES presents "a clear opportunity.... For health promotion and disease prevention efforts to improve the health prospects and functional independence of people with disabilities." As a corollary to this, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have recommended the development of techniques to prevent or ameliorate secondary disabilities in persons with a SCI. Patients with SCI have an increased susceptibility to cardiac morbidity and mortality in the acute and early stages of their injury. Most of these patients make an excellent adaptation except when confronted with infection or hypoxia. SCI by itself does not promote atherosclerosis; however, in association with multiple secondary conditions related to SCI, along with advancing age, patients with SCI are predisposed to relatively greater risk of heart disease. The epidemiologic significance of this is reflected in demographic studies that indicate an increasing number of SCI patients becoming aged. Currently 71,000 (40%) of the total 179,000 patients with SCI living in the United States are older than 40 years, and 45,000 have injuries sustained more than 20 years earlier. In addition, new injuries in the older population are increasing (currently 11% of all injuries), and some of these new patients with SCI already have pre-existing cardiac disease. Studies have demonstrated that improved lifestyle, physical activity, lipid management, and dietary restrictions can affect major risk factors for coronary artery disease. Therefore an aggressive cardiac prevention program is appropriate for patients with SCI as part of their rehabilitation. At a given submaximal workload, arm exercise is performed at a greater physiologic cost than is leg exercise. At maximal effort, however, physiologic responses are generally greater in leg exercise than arm exercise. Arm exercise is less efficient and less effective than lower body exercise in developing and maintaining both central and peripheral aspects of cardiovascular fitness. The situation is further compounded in SCI because of poor venous return as a result of lower-limb blood pooling, as a result of lack of sympathetic tone, and a diminished or absent venous "muscle pump" in the legs. This latter mechanism perhaps contributes the greatest diminution in the potential for aerobic performance in the SCI population. Obtaining a cardiopulmonary training effect in individuals with SCI is quite possible. Current studies indicate decreases in submaximal HR, respiratory quotient, minute ventilation, and oxygen uptake, with increases in maximal power output, oxygen uptake, minute ventilation, and lactic acid. Individuals with SCI have been shown to benefit from lower limb functional electrical stimulation (FES)-induced exercise. Studies have consistently reported increases in lower limb strength and cycle endurance performance with these protocols, as well as improvements in metabolic and
使用各种功能性电刺激(FES)方案来促进身体活动增加、增强身体素质并降低心脏病风险是一个相对较新但正在不断发展的研究领域。目前的证据支持其用于改善脊髓损伤(SCI)患者的潜在健康益处。这些益处可能包括更高效、更安全的心脏功能;对代谢、心血管和肺部训练适应的更大刺激;以及对骨骼肌训练适应的更大刺激。此外,相对便宜的商用FES装置可引发肌肉收缩,无凝胶、可重复使用电极易于使用,以及家用和商用上身运动设备越来越普及,这意味着通过提高便利性和降低成本,SCI人群更有可能获得这些益处。美国卫生与公众服务部已将SCI患者确定为“特殊人群”,他们的健康问题更为突出,因此需要专门解决。FES“为健康促进和疾病预防努力改善残疾人的健康前景和功能独立性提供了一个明确的机会”。与此相关的是,疾病控制与预防中心建议开发预防或改善SCI患者继发性残疾的技术。SCI患者在损伤的急性期和早期,心脏发病和死亡的易感性增加。除了感染或缺氧的情况外,大多数这类患者都能很好地适应。SCI本身不会促进动脉粥样硬化;然而,与SCI相关的多种继发性疾病以及年龄增长相关联,SCI患者患心脏病的风险相对更高。这在人口统计学研究中有所体现,这些研究表明年龄较大的SCI患者数量在增加。目前,居住在美国的179,000名SCI患者中,有71,000名(40%)年龄超过40岁,45,000名患者的损伤发生在20多年前。此外,老年人群中的新损伤也在增加(目前占所有损伤的11%),其中一些新的SCI患者已经患有心脏病。研究表明,改善生活方式、身体活动、脂质管理和饮食限制可以影响冠状动脉疾病的主要危险因素。因此,积极的心脏预防计划作为康复的一部分,对SCI患者是合适的。在给定的次最大工作量下,手臂运动比腿部运动消耗的生理成本更高。然而,在最大努力时,腿部运动的生理反应通常比手臂运动更大。在发展和维持心血管健康的中枢和外周方面,手臂运动比下肢运动效率更低、效果更差。由于下肢血液淤积导致静脉回流不畅,缺乏交感神经张力,以及腿部静脉“肌肉泵”减弱或缺失,SCI患者的情况更加复杂。后一种机制可能是导致SCI人群有氧能力下降的最大因素。在SCI个体中获得心肺训练效果是完全可能的。目前的研究表明,次最大心率、呼吸商、分钟通气量和摄氧量降低,同时最大功率输出、摄氧量、分钟通气量和乳酸增加。已证明SCI个体可从下肢功能性电刺激(FES)诱导的运动中受益。研究一致报告称,采用这些方案可使下肢力量和骑行耐力表现增加,以及代谢和……方面得到改善