Williams D M, Kasting J F, Frakes L A
School of Science, Penn State Erie, The Behrend College, Pennsylvania 16563-0203, USA.
Nature. 1998 Dec 3;396(6710):453-5. doi: 10.1038/24845.
Palaeomagnetic data suggest that the Earth was glaciated at low latitudes during the Palaeoproterozoic (about 2.4-2.2 Gyr ago) and Neoproterozoic (about 820-550 Myr ago) eras, although some of the Neoproterozoic data are disputed. If the Earth's magnetic field was aligned more or less with its spin axis, as it is today, then either the polar ice caps must have extended well down into the tropics-the 'snowball Earth' hypothesis-or the present zonation of climate with respect to latitude must have been reversed. Williams has suggested that the Earth's obliquity may have been greater than 54 degrees during most of its history, which would have made the Equator the coldest part of the planet. But this would require a mechanism to bring the obliquity down to its present value of 23.5 degrees. Here we propose that obliquity-oblateness feedback could have reduced the Earth's obliquity by tens of degrees in less than 100 Myr if the continents were situated so as to promote the formation of large polar ice sheets. A high obliquity for the early Earth may also provide a natural explanation for the present inclination of the lunar orbit with respect to the ecliptic (5 degrees), which is otherwise difficult to explain.
古地磁数据表明,在古元古代(约24亿至22亿年前)和新元古代(约8.2亿至5.5亿年前)时期,地球在低纬度地区曾经历过冰川作用,尽管新元古代的一些数据存在争议。如果地球磁场像现在这样大致与自转轴对齐,那么要么极地冰盖必然延伸至热带地区——即“雪球地球”假说——要么当前气候随纬度的分带情况必然相反。威廉姆斯提出,在地球历史的大部分时间里,其倾角可能大于54度,这会使赤道成为地球最冷的区域。但这需要一种机制将倾角降至目前的23.5度。我们在此提出,如果大陆的分布有利于大型极地冰盖的形成,那么倾角 - 扁率反馈可能在不到10亿年的时间里将地球倾角降低数十度。早期地球的高倾角也可能为月球轨道目前相对于黄道的倾角(5度)提供一个自然的解释,否则这很难解释。