Marshall E G, Geary N S, Cayo M R, Lauridsen P A
New York State Department of Health, Albany 12208, USA.
J Expo Anal Environ Epidemiol. 1993;3 Suppl 1:87-98.
Evaluation of associations between residence near hazardous waste sites and rare outcomes requires the consideration of large geographic areas and multiple sources of contamination. For a case-control study of birth defects and solvents, metals and pesticide exposure, the authors rely on previously collected data to rate possible residential exposure from hazardous waste sites. Four pathways of exposure are evaluated: air vapor, air particulates, groundwater ingestion, and groundwater inhalation. Areas within one mile of each site are classified according to 1) the probability of exposure to solvents, metals, and pesticides, and, if available, 2) the relative concentration of contaminants. The probability of exposure (low, medium, or high) for air vapor and particulates depends on the evaporation and soil retention potential of the contaminants, degree of containment, predominant wind direction, and size of the contaminated area. The probability of exposure for groundwater ingestion and inhalation depends on whether there are water supply wells or affected basements within one mile, solubility of the contaminants, direction of groundwater flow, and groundwater sampling results. Relative concentration is based on sampling results for the most commonly sampled media. Exposures are shown on a standard template that defines 25 sectors within a 1 mile radius of each site. The method cannot provide exact estimates of residential exposure, because it relies on data of variable quality. It does provide a basis for evaluating health effects at multiple sites by identifying susceptible residential areas.
评估居住在危险废物场地附近与罕见结果之间的关联需要考虑大面积的地理区域和多种污染源。对于一项关于出生缺陷与溶剂、金属和农药暴露的病例对照研究,作者依靠先前收集的数据来评估来自危险废物场地的可能的居住暴露情况。评估了四种暴露途径:空气蒸气、空气颗粒物、地下水摄入和地下水吸入。每个场地一英里范围内的区域根据以下因素进行分类:1)接触溶剂、金属和农药的可能性,以及(如有)2)污染物的相对浓度。空气蒸气和颗粒物的暴露可能性(低、中或高)取决于污染物的蒸发和土壤保留潜力、遏制程度、主导风向以及污染区域的大小。地下水摄入和吸入的暴露可能性取决于一英里范围内是否有供水井或受影响的地下室、污染物的溶解度、地下水流向以及地下水采样结果。相对浓度基于最常采样介质的采样结果。暴露情况显示在一个标准模板上,该模板在每个场地一英里半径内定义了25个扇区。该方法无法提供居住暴露的确切估计值,因为它依赖于质量参差不齐的数据。它确实为通过识别易感居住区来评估多个场地的健康影响提供了一个基础。