O'Driscoll M C, Scott D, Orton C J, Kiltie A E, Davidson S E, Hunter R D, West C M
Cancer Research Campaign Section of Genome Damage and Repair, Paterson Institute for Cancer Research, Christie Hospital (NHS) Trust, Manchester, UK.
Br J Cancer. 1998 Dec;78(12):1559-63. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1998.723.
As part of our programme for developing predictive tests for normal tissue response to radiotherapy, we have investigated the efficacy of the cytokinesis-block micronucleus (MN) assay as a means of detecting interindividual differences in cellular radiosensitivity. A study was made of nine fibroblast strains established from vaginal biopsies of pretreatment cervical cancer patients and an ataxia telangiectasia (A-T) cell strain. Cells were irradiated in plateau phase, replated and treated with cytochalasin B 24 h later. MN formation was examined 72 h after irradiation as the number of MN in 100 binucleate cells. The method yielded low spontaneous MN yields (<7 per 100 cells), and mean induced MN frequencies after 3.5 Gy varied between cell strains from 18 to 144 per 100 cells. However, in repeat experiments, considerable intrastrain variability was observed (CV = 32%), with up to twofold differences in MN yields, although this was less than interstrain variability (CV = 62%). An analysis was made of the relationship between MN results and previously obtained clonogenic survival data. There was a significant correlation between MN yields and clonogenic survival. However, when the A-T strain was excluded from the analysis, the correlation lost significance, mainly because of one slow-growing strain which was the most sensitive to cell killing but had almost the lowest MN frequency. With current methodology, the MN assay on human fibroblasts does not appear to have a role in predictive testing of normal tissue radiosensitivity.
作为我们开发正常组织对放疗反应预测性检测项目的一部分,我们研究了胞质分裂阻滞微核(MN)试验作为检测细胞放射敏感性个体差异方法的有效性。对从宫颈癌患者放疗前阴道活检组织中建立的9种成纤维细胞系和一种共济失调毛细血管扩张症(A-T)细胞系进行了研究。细胞在平台期接受照射,重新接种,24小时后用细胞松弛素B处理。照射72小时后检查微核形成情况,以100个双核细胞中的微核数量为准。该方法产生的自发微核率较低(每100个细胞<7个),3.5 Gy照射后平均诱导微核频率在不同细胞系之间为每100个细胞18至144个。然而,在重复实验中,观察到相当大的菌株内变异性(CV = 32%),微核产量差异高达两倍,尽管这小于菌株间变异性(CV = 62%)。分析了微核结果与先前获得的克隆形成存活数据之间的关系。微核产量与克隆形成存活之间存在显著相关性。然而,当将A-T细胞系排除在分析之外时,相关性失去了显著性,主要是因为有一个生长缓慢的细胞系,它对细胞杀伤最敏感,但微核频率几乎最低。就目前的方法而言,人成纤维细胞的微核试验似乎在正常组织放射敏感性的预测性检测中没有作用。