Rob M I, Corben P, Rushworth R L
New South Wales Health Department, North Sydney, Australia.
J Qual Clin Pract. 1998 Dec;18(4):263-74. doi: 10.1046/j.1440-1762.1998.00282.x.
This study examined the impact of the introduction of laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) on the rate and pattern of cholecystectomy in New South Wales, Australia. An analysis of the hospital data for the period 1981-94/95 was performed, which encompassed patients of both public and private hospitals. Cholecystectomy rates in the years after the introduction of LC in mid-1990 were 24% higher on average than rates in the prior years and rose from an average 1.68-2.09 per 1000. In the 5-year period of the study after the introduction of LC, the average age of private hospital patients increased from 50.6 to 53.4 years, while that of public hospital patients declined slightly from 53.5 to 52.4 years. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy was introduced more rapidly in private than public hospitals. By June 1995, 96% of private compared with 71% of public hospitals had introduced LC, and cholecystectomy patients in private hospitals were more likely to have laparoscopic surgery than patients in public hospitals (92% compared with 80%). The introduction of LC has been accompanied by a marked and sustained increase in the cholecystectomy rate. While the unit cost for the laparoscopic procedure is lower because of a shorter length of stay, the increase in the number of procedures means that there have been no net savings for the health system from the increased efficiency. While the new procedure offers superior advantages to patients with symptomatic gallbladder disease, the effect of the apparent lower threshold for surgery needs investigation.
本研究考察了腹腔镜胆囊切除术(LC)的引入对澳大利亚新南威尔士州胆囊切除术的发生率及模式的影响。对1981年至1994/95年期间的医院数据进行了分析,涵盖了公立医院和私立医院的患者。1990年年中引入LC后的几年里,胆囊切除术的发生率平均比之前几年高24%,从每1000人平均1.68例升至2.09例。在引入LC后的5年研究期内,私立医院患者的平均年龄从50.6岁增至53.4岁,而公立医院患者的平均年龄则从53.5岁略降至52.4岁。腹腔镜胆囊切除术在私立医院的引入速度比公立医院更快。到1995年6月,96%的私立医院与71%的公立医院已引入LC,私立医院的胆囊切除术患者比公立医院的患者更有可能接受腹腔镜手术(分别为92%和80%)。LC的引入伴随着胆囊切除术发生率的显著且持续上升。虽然由于住院时间缩短,腹腔镜手术的单位成本较低,但手术数量的增加意味着卫生系统并未因效率提高而实现净节省。虽然新手术为有症状胆囊疾病患者带来了更大优势,但手术门槛明显降低所产生的影响仍需调查。