Kostowski W, Bieńkowski P
Department of Pharmacology & Physiology of the Nervous System, Institute of Psychiatry & Neurology, Warsaw, Poland.
Alcohol. 1999 Jan;17(1):63-80. doi: 10.1016/s0741-8329(98)00035-4.
Generally, compounds discriminated by animals possess psychotropic effects in animals and humans. As with many other drugs of abuse, strength of the ethanol discriminative stimulus is dose related. The majority of studies show that doses close to 1.0 g/kg are close to the minimum at which the discrimination can be learned easily. Substitution studies suggest that anxiolytic, sedative, atactic, and myorelaxant effects of ethanol all play an important role in the formation of its intercoeptive stimulus. Low doses of ethanol produce more excitatory cues, similar to amphetamine-like subjective stimuli, whereas higher doses produce rather sedative/hypnotic stimuli similar to those elicited by barbiturates. Substitution studies have shown that the complete substitution for ethanol may be exerted by certain GABA-mimetic drugs acting through different sites within the GABA(A)-benzodiazepine receptor complex (e.g., diazepam, pentobarbital, certain neurosteroids), gamma-hydroxybutyrate, and antagonists of the glutamate NMDA receptor. Among the NMDA receptor antagonists both noncompetitive (e.g., dizocilpine) and competitive antagonists (e.g., CGP 40116) are capable of substituting for ethanol. Further, some antagonists of strychnine-insensitive glycine modulatory sites among the NMDA receptor complex (e.g., L-701,324) dose-dependently substitute for the ethanol discriminative stimulus. On the other hand, neither GABA-benzodiazepine antagonists nor NMDA receptor agonists produce contradictory effects (i.e., reduce the ethanol discriminative stimulus). There is influence of a particular training dose of ethanol on the substitution pattern of different compounds. For example, 5-HT(1B/2C) agonists substitute for intermediate (1.0 g/kg) but not higher (2.0 g/kg) ethanol training doses. Discrimination studies with ethanol and drugs acting on NMDA and GABA receptors consistently indicate asymmetrical generalization. For example, ethanol is able to generalize to barbiturates and benzodiazepines, but neither the benzodiazepine nor barbiturate response generalizes to ethanol. Only a few drugs are able to antagonize, at least to some extent, the discriminative stimulus of ethanol (e.g., partial inverse GABA-benzodiazepine receptor antagonist Ro 15-4513 and the opioid antagonist naloxone). The ethanol stimulus effect may be increased (i.e., stronger recognition) by N-cholinergic drugs (nicotine), dopaminergic drugs (apomorphine), and 5-HT3 receptor agonists (m-chlorophenylbiguanide). Thus, the ethanol stimulus is composed of the several components, with the NMDA receptor and GABA(A) receptor complex being of particular importance. This suggests that a drug mixture may be more capable of substituting for ethanol (or block its stimulus) than a single compound. The ability of drugs to substitute for the ethanol discriminative stimulus is frequently, although not preclusively, associated with the reduction of voluntary ethanol consumption. The examples of positive correlation are gamma-hydroxybutyrate, possibly memantine and certain serotonergic drugs such as fluoxetine. However, it remains uncertain to what extent the discriminative stimulus of ethanol can be seen as relevant in the understanding of the complex mechanisms of dependence.
一般来说,动物能够区分的化合物在动物和人类中都具有精神活性作用。与许多其他滥用药物一样,乙醇辨别刺激的强度与剂量相关。大多数研究表明,接近1.0 g/kg的剂量接近能够轻松习得辨别的最低剂量。替代研究表明,乙醇的抗焦虑、镇静、共济失调和肌松作用在其内部感受性刺激的形成中都起着重要作用。低剂量乙醇产生更多兴奋性线索,类似于苯丙胺样主观刺激,而高剂量则产生类似于巴比妥类药物引起的镇静/催眠刺激。替代研究表明,某些通过GABA(A)-苯二氮䓬受体复合物内不同位点起作用的GABA模拟药物(如地西泮、戊巴比妥、某些神经甾体)、γ-羟基丁酸酯和谷氨酸NMDA受体拮抗剂能够完全替代乙醇。在NMDA受体拮抗剂中,非竞争性拮抗剂(如地佐环平)和竞争性拮抗剂(如CGP 40116)都能够替代乙醇。此外,NMDA受体复合物中对士的宁不敏感的甘氨酸调节位点的一些拮抗剂(如L-701,324)剂量依赖性地替代乙醇辨别刺激。另一方面,GABA-苯二氮䓬拮抗剂和NMDA受体激动剂都不会产生相反的作用(即减少乙醇辨别刺激)。特定的乙醇训练剂量会对不同化合物的替代模式产生影响。例如,5-HT(1B/2C)激动剂能够替代中等剂量(1.0 g/kg)而非高剂量(2.0 g/kg)的乙醇训练剂量。对乙醇以及作用于NMDA和GABA受体的药物进行的辨别研究一致表明存在不对称泛化。例如,乙醇能够泛化到巴比妥类药物和苯二氮䓬类药物,但苯二氮䓬类药物和巴比妥类药物的反应都不会泛化到乙醇。只有少数药物能够至少在一定程度上拮抗乙醇的辨别刺激(如部分反向GABA-苯二氮䓬受体拮抗剂Ro 15-4513和阿片受体拮抗剂纳洛酮)。N-胆碱能药物(尼古丁)、多巴胺能药物(阿扑吗啡)和5-HT3受体激动剂(间氯苯基双胍)可能会增强乙醇刺激效应(即更强识别)。因此,乙醇刺激由多个成分组成,其中NMDA受体和GABA(A)受体复合物尤为重要。这表明药物混合物可能比单一化合物更有能力替代乙醇(或阻断其刺激)。药物替代乙醇辨别刺激的能力虽然并非绝对,但经常与自愿乙醇消耗量的减少相关。正相关的例子有γ-羟基丁酸酯、可能还有美金刚以及某些血清素能药物如氟西汀。然而,乙醇辨别刺激在理解复杂的成瘾机制中究竟能在多大程度上被视为相关因素仍不确定。