Shamsuddin L, Rouf S, Khan J H, Tamanna S, Hussain A Z, Samsuddin A K
Deptt. of Obst. & Gynae., Institute of Post Graduate Medicine & Research, Dhaka.
Bangladesh Med Res Counc Bull. 1998 Aug;24(2):43-8.
This clinical trial was conducted to compare the anticonvulsant response of magnesium sulphate and diazepam in the management of eclampsia. The study was carried out at the eclampsia unit of Dhaka Medical College Hospital during the period from October, 1995 to January, 1996. Two hundred consecutive admitted patients were recruited for the study and randomly assigned to two treatment groups: magnesium sulphate and diazepam. One hundred patients received injection magnesium sulphate and another one hundred received injection diazepam. All patients of both the group were matched for baseline characteristics. Convulsion was controlled in 95% of the patients of magnesium sulphate group and 74% of the patients of diazepam group (p < .0005). The mean controlling time is also significantly lower in magnesium sulphate group than diazepam group (8.50 hours vs 9.39 hours). Patients of magnesium sulphate group regain consciousness much earlier (mean time 20.62 hrs.) than the patients of diazepam group (mean time 40.62 hrs.). No significant difference was observed in controlling blood pressure and foetal outcome. The study finding shows that magnesium sulphate has some advantage over diazepam in controlling convulsion and regaining consciousness. If magnesium sulphate can be made available in the market by local production it may be recommended to use this drug in the primary health care without any hazzard before referring to other hospital.
本临床试验旨在比较硫酸镁和地西泮在子痫治疗中的抗惊厥反应。该研究于1995年10月至1996年1月期间在达卡医学院医院的子痫病房进行。连续招募了200名入院患者进行研究,并随机分为两个治疗组:硫酸镁组和地西泮组。100名患者接受硫酸镁注射,另外100名患者接受地西泮注射。两组所有患者的基线特征均相匹配。硫酸镁组95%的患者惊厥得到控制,地西泮组为74%(p < .0005)。硫酸镁组的平均控制时间也显著低于地西泮组(8.50小时对9.39小时)。硫酸镁组患者恢复意识的时间(平均时间20.62小时)比地西泮组患者(平均时间40.62小时)早得多。在控制血压和胎儿结局方面未观察到显著差异。研究结果表明,硫酸镁在控制惊厥和恢复意识方面比地西泮具有一些优势。如果能通过本地生产使硫酸镁在市场上可得,在转诊至其他医院之前,建议在初级卫生保健中使用这种药物且无任何风险。