Musch E, Högemann B, Gerritzen A, Fischer H P, Wiese M, Kruis W, Malek M, Gugler R, Schmidt G, Huchzermeyer H, Gerlach U, Dengler H J, Sauerbruch T
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Bonn, Germany.
Hepatogastroenterology. 1998 Nov-Dec;45(24):2282-94.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: Alpha-interferon (IFN-alpha) is an effective treatment for chronic hepatitis B but only 25-40% of patients will profit from a long-term beneficial response to the currently recommended schedule of 3-6 MU given 3 times a week for 6 months. Clinical trials are therefore needed to investigate alternative modifications of interferon therapy, including combinations of different antivirals or immune modulators in order to improve the therapeutic approach to chronic hepatitis B infection. In a phase II trial we evaluated whether a combination of natural interferon-beta (nIFN-beta) with strong antiviral activity plus recombinant interferon-gamma (rIFN-gamma) with a predominantly immunomodulatory activity is able to increase the response rate compared to historical controls treated with IFN-alpha in a conventional regimen.
Forty patients with chronic hepatitis B were included in this trial of combined interferon therapy at a dosage of 6 MU nIFN-beta during week 1 followed by 3 MU for weeks 2-4 plus rIFN-gamma at a daily subcutaneous (s.c.) injection of 150 microg during the entire 4 weeks of the treatment period. Patients entered the trial on the basis of the following criteria: hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAG), HBeAG and HBV-DNA positive for at least 6 months, HDV, EBV, CMV, anti-HIV negative, and chronic hepatitis proven on biopsy taken within 4 weeks of entry as well as 6 and/or 12 months after interferon therapy. The final diagnosis and classification of chronic hepatitis has been based on guidelines according to a revised classification of chronic hepatitis (Desmet 1994). The post-treatment follow-up was 12 months.
The combined interferon therapy achieved complete responses with seroconversion from HBeAG to anti-HBe and a negative HBV-DNA (dot blot) test, as well as normalization of ALT activity in 15 patients, and partial response with negativation of HBV-DNA concomitant to a decrease in aminotransferase activity to near normal levels in 6 patients. Nineteen patients showed no response to viral markers but showed relief of clinical symptoms as well as pronounced decrease of serumtransaminase activity. Grading of liver biopsies demonstrated an improvement of histologic parameters after the interferon regimen in half of the evaluable patients (n=22). Histological response has been quantified by a reduction in the score of histological activity (HAI-index) from 12.6 before to 7.6 after interferon therapy, and in the inflammation and cellular degeneration score (ICD) from 9.9 to 5.2. Histological response, however, failed to show a consistent correlation with serologic response. This medium-dose combination of interferon-beta and interferon-gamma was tolerated very well by the patients, this good tolerability being explained by tachyphylaxis in response to daily interferon doses. No serious side effects or decompensation of liver function were observed during the 4-week period of therapy or the follow-up, despite the special clinical situation where 60% of the patients included in the study presented with histologically proven cirrhosis (35% of them with clinical manifestation of mildly decompensated cirrhosis).
This short-term regimen of combined nIFN-beta + rIFN-gamma therapy in patients with chronic hepatitis B proved to be equieffective to long-term treatment with interferon-alpha and combines high clinical tolerability with good practicability, as it can be administered on an in-patient basis, ensuring close patient monitoring.
背景/目的:α-干扰素(IFN-α)是治疗慢性乙型肝炎的有效药物,但目前推荐的每周3次、每次3 - 6 MU、持续6个月的治疗方案,仅有25% - 40%的患者能获得长期有益反应。因此,需要进行临床试验来研究干扰素治疗的替代方案,包括不同抗病毒药物或免疫调节剂的联合使用,以改进慢性乙型肝炎感染的治疗方法。在一项II期试验中,我们评估了具有强大抗病毒活性的天然β-干扰素(nIFN-β)与主要具有免疫调节活性的重组γ-干扰素(rIFN-γ)联合使用,与采用传统方案接受IFN-α治疗的历史对照相比,是否能够提高应答率。
40例慢性乙型肝炎患者纳入该联合干扰素治疗试验,第1周给予6 MU nIFN-β,第2 - 4周给予3 MU,整个4周治疗期内每日皮下注射150 μg rIFN-γ。患者入组依据以下标准:乙肝表面抗原(HBsAG)、HBeAG和HBV-DNA阳性至少6个月,HDV、EBV、CMV、抗HIV阴性,且在入组后4周内以及干扰素治疗后6个月和/或12个月时经活检证实为慢性肝炎。慢性肝炎的最终诊断和分类依据慢性肝炎修订分类指南(Desmet 1994)。治疗后随访12个月。
联合干扰素治疗使15例患者实现完全应答,表现为HBeAG血清学转换为抗-HBe且HBV-DNA(斑点印迹法)检测阴性,同时ALT活性恢复正常;6例患者部分应答,HBV-DNA转阴且转氨酶活性降至接近正常水平。19例患者病毒标志物无应答,但临床症状缓解且血清转氨酶活性显著降低。肝活检分级显示,半数可评估患者(n = 22)在干扰素治疗后组织学参数有所改善。组织学应答通过组织学活动度评分(HAI指数)从干扰素治疗前的12.6降至治疗后的7.6,以及炎症和细胞变性评分(ICD)从9.9降至5.2来量化。然而,组织学应答与血清学应答未显示出一致的相关性。患者对这种中剂量的β-干扰素和γ-干扰素联合治疗耐受性良好,这种良好的耐受性可归因于对每日干扰素剂量的快速耐受。在4周治疗期及随访期间,未观察到严重副作用或肝功能失代偿,尽管研究纳入的患者中有60%经组织学证实为肝硬化(其中35%有轻度失代偿性肝硬化临床表现)这一特殊临床情况。
对于慢性乙型肝炎患者,这种nIFN-β + rIFN-γ联合治疗的短期方案被证明与IFN-α长期治疗等效,且具有高临床耐受性和良好实用性,因为它可在住院基础上给药,确保对患者进行密切监测。