Weber T R, Fortuna R S, Silen M L, Dillon P A
Department of Surgery, St. Louis University School of Medicine and Cardinal Glennon Children's Hospital, MO 63104, USA.
J Pediatr Surg. 1999 Jan;34(1):153-6; discussion 156-7. doi: 10.1016/s0022-3468(99)90247-6.
BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: Reoperation for Hirschsprung's disease traditionally has been used for patients with anastomotic leaks or stricture or with severe constipation from retained aganglionic segment or neuronal dysplasia, but there is little information regarding its use for other complications and the long-term outcome in these patients.
In a 23-year period, 107 infants and children underwent Soave (68 patients) or Duhamel (39 patients) pull-through procedures. The age at operation was newborn to 6 years (mean, 10 months). Eighty percent had aganglionosis limited to the rectosigmoid colon. Follow-up was by office visit or telephone (mean, 8.5 years).
Twenty-three of the 68 patients with Soave pull-through (34%) underwent reoperation for intractable enterocolitis (10 patients, all 10 cured); anastomotic stenosis (four patients, three cured, one continued diversion); anastomotic leak (four patients, four cured); retained aganglionic segment (three patients, three cured); one necrosis of pull-through converted to Duhamel and cured; and one rectal prolapse that was diverted. Fifteen of the 39 patients with Duhamel procedure (38%) underwent reoperation for severe constipation (seven patients, six cured, one diverted); persistent rectal septum (four patients, 4 cured); and intractable enterocolitis (four patients, three cured, one diverted). Overall, 21 of 23 patients (91%) with reoperation after Soave procedures were cured, whereas 13 of 15 patients (87%) who underwent reoperation after Duhamel procedure were cured, and four patients remain diverted.
These data show that aggressive reoperation can result in a high cure rate in Hirschsprung's disease. Although there is no significant difference in the rate of reoperation after Duhamel and Soave procedures, the patients with Soave pull-through required more complex reoperations, with several requiring more than one procedure. An aggressive approach to reoperation in patients with Hirschsprung's disease clearly is justified.
背景/目的:先天性巨结肠症的再次手术传统上用于吻合口漏、狭窄或因残留无神经节段或神经元发育异常导致严重便秘的患者,但关于其用于其他并发症及这些患者的长期预后的信息较少。
在23年期间,107例婴幼儿接受了Soave术(68例)或Duhamel术(39例)拖出手术。手术年龄为新生儿至6岁(平均10个月)。80%的患者无神经节症局限于直肠乙状结肠。通过门诊或电话随访(平均8.5年)。
68例行Soave拖出术的患者中有23例(34%)因难治性小肠结肠炎再次手术(10例,全部治愈);吻合口狭窄(4例,3例治愈,1例持续改道);吻合口漏(4例,全部治愈);残留无神经节段(3例,全部治愈);1例拖出段坏死改行Duhamel术并治愈;1例直肠脱垂改道。39例行Duhamel术的患者中有15例(38%)因严重便秘再次手术(7例,6例治愈,1例改道);持续性直肠隔(4例,全部治愈);难治性小肠结肠炎(4例,3例治愈,1例改道)。总体而言,23例Soave术后再次手术的患者中有21例(91%)治愈,而15例Duhamel术后再次手术的患者中有13例(87%)治愈,4例患者仍需改道。
这些数据表明,积极的再次手术可使先天性巨结肠症的治愈率较高。虽然Duhamel术和Soave术后再次手术率无显著差异,但行Soave拖出术的患者需要更复杂的再次手术,部分患者需要不止一次手术。对先天性巨结肠症患者采取积极的再次手术方法显然是合理的。