Rorije E, Loonen H, Müller M, Klopman G, Peijnenburg W J
Laboratory for Ecotoxicology, Nat. Inst. Public Health and The Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
Chemosphere. 1999 Mar;38(6):1409-17. doi: 10.1016/s0045-6535(98)00543-8.
Three existing models and one newly developed model for the prediction of ready biodegradability of organic compounds are evaluated by comparing the descriptors they use, and the consistency of the models when applied to the set of High Production Volume Chemicals (HPVC) in the European Union. Linear regression models developed for the OECD showed the best performance in the external validation (84.7% correct), although comparison with the other three models is flawed because of the class specificity of these models. With these models 567 of the 894 compounds could be predicted in the validation. The multivariate statistical model showed the best performance in the external validation (82.7% correct) combined with the broadest applicability of the model. The evaluation of the predictions of the models for the HPVC shows that all models are highly consistent in their prediction of not-ready biodegradability, but much less consistency is seen in the prediction of ready biodegradability. This complies with the observation that all 4 models show better performance in their predictions of not-ready biodegradability.
通过比较现有三种模型和一种新开发的用于预测有机化合物易生物降解性的模型所使用的描述符,以及这些模型应用于欧盟高产量化学品(HPVC)数据集时的一致性,对它们进行了评估。为经合组织(OECD)开发的线性回归模型在外部验证中表现最佳(正确率84.7%),不过由于这些模型的类别特异性,与其他三种模型的比较存在缺陷。使用这些模型可在验证中预测894种化合物中的567种。多变量统计模型在外部验证中表现最佳(正确率82.7%),且模型的适用性最广。对HPVC模型预测结果的评估表明,所有模型在预测不易生物降解性方面高度一致,但在预测易生物降解性方面一致性较低。这与所有4种模型在预测不易生物降解性方面表现更好的观察结果相符。