Duncan C, Jones K, Moon G
Institute for the Geography of Health, Department of Geography, University of Portsmouth, UK.
Soc Sci Med. 1999 Feb;48(4):497-505. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(98)00360-8.
Debate has centred on whether the character of places plays an independent role in shaping individual smoking behaviour. At the small-area scale, particular attention has focused on whether measures of neighbourhood deprivation predict an individual's smoking status independent of their own personal characteristics. This study applies multilevel modelling techniques to data from the British Health and Lifestyle Survey and ward (local neighbourhood) level deprivation scores based on four variables from the national Census. Results suggest that after taking account of a large range of individual characteristics, both as main effects and interactions, together with complex structures of between-individual variation, measures of neighbourhood deprivation continue to have an independent effect on individual smoking status. In addition, significant between-ward differences in smoking behaviour remain which cannot be explained either by population composition or ward-level deprivation. The study suggests that the character of the local neighbourhood plays a role in shaping smoking behaviour.
争论主要集中在场所特征是否在塑造个人吸烟行为方面发挥独立作用。在小区域尺度上,特别关注邻里贫困程度的衡量指标是否能独立于个人自身特征来预测个人的吸烟状况。本研究将多层次建模技术应用于来自英国健康与生活方式调查的数据,以及基于全国人口普查的四个变量得出的选区(当地邻里)层面的贫困得分。结果表明,在考虑了一系列作为主要效应和交互作用的个人特征,以及个体间变异的复杂结构之后,邻里贫困程度的衡量指标对个人吸烟状况仍具有独立影响。此外,吸烟行为在选区之间存在显著差异,这既不能用人口构成来解释,也不能用选区层面的贫困来解释。该研究表明,当地邻里的特征在塑造吸烟行为方面发挥着作用。