Elkharrat D, Chastang C, Lecorre A, Caulin C
Service des Urgences, Hôpital Lariboisière, Paris, France.
Am J Ther. 1998 Jul;5(4):225-32. doi: 10.1097/00045391-199807000-00004.
Guidelines for the prescription of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), drawn in the Health Ministry and published by the Drug Regulatory Agency, were introduced in the emergency department of a university hospital. The main objective was to determine, in this prospective, before-and-after study, whether a teaching program could help doctors improve their NSAID prescribing practices. Correct prescribing included limiting NSAIDs to their most admitted indications, avoiding their prescription to accident-prone patients, and reducing treatment duration and daily dosage. An overall reduction of NSAID prescriptions was also expected. Prescribing errors were divided into violations (prescribing when unwarranted or against a contraindication) and inadequacies (if the compound or treatment schedule was not suited to the condition addressed). We measured the effect of the intervention 45 days after its initiation. Twenty-seven doctors participated in the two study phases (595 and 520 patients) and wrote 50 NSAID prescriptions in each (8.4% and 9. 6% of patients, respectively; P = 0.44). Prescribing errors decreased from 20% to 14% of cases (P = 0.60). There was a trend toward more prescriptions conforming to the Drug Regulatory Agency guidelines (P = 0.08). Treatment duration decreased from 10.4 +/- 5. 4 to 9.0 +/- 4.0 days (P = 0.03). The teaching of guidelines has helped physicians to improve their NSAID prescribing practices; however, it did not succeed in curbing the overall prescription rate. Unrestricted lists that include soft indications may influence younger doctors into prescribing more NSAIDs.
由卫生部制定并经药品监管机构发布的非甾体抗炎药(NSAIDs)处方指南在一家大学医院的急诊科实施。这项前瞻性前后对照研究的主要目的是确定一个教学项目是否能帮助医生改进他们开具NSAIDs的做法。正确的处方包括将NSAIDs限制在最常见的适应症范围内,避免给易发生意外的患者开具此类药物,并缩短治疗时间和降低每日剂量。预计NSAIDs的处方总量也会减少。处方错误分为违规(在无必要或有禁忌症时开具)和不适当(如果药物或治疗方案不适合所治疗的病情)。我们在干预开始45天后测量其效果。27名医生参与了两个研究阶段(分别有595名和520名患者),每个阶段开具了50份NSAIDs处方(分别占患者的8.4%和9.6%;P = 0.44)。处方错误的病例比例从20%降至14%(P = 0.60)。符合药品监管机构指南的处方有增加的趋势(P = 0.08)。治疗时间从10.4±5.4天降至9.0±4.0天(P = 0.03)。指南教学有助于医生改进他们开具NSAIDs的做法;然而,它未能成功抑制总体处方率。包含轻微适应症的无限制清单可能会影响年轻医生开具更多的NSAIDs。