Bryson H M, Whittington R
Adis International Limited, Auckland, New Zealand.
Pharmacoeconomics. 1994 Dec;6(6):563-77. doi: 10.2165/00019053-199406060-00009.
Comprehensive clinical data provide strong evidence of the efficacy of the synthetic lung surfactant colfosceril palmitate (Exosurf Neonatal) administered as prophylaxis or rescue therapy in infants with respiratory distress syndrome (RDS). The use of rescue therapy with colfosceril palmitate is further supported by cost-effectiveness analyses which report a 9 to 48% reduction in the cost per survivor compared with placebo or historical controls, despite divergent study methodology and location. Importantly, the savings were evident in both larger (> or = 1250g) and smaller (700 to 1350g) infants. All studies considered costs or charges accrued during initial hospitalisation through to 1 year; measurement of long term resource use data and all resulting costs are required for a more complete pharmacoeconomic evaluation. The optimal timing of surfactant administration is likely to be an important economic issue given that efficacy data from a large international trial support earlier administration of colfosceril palmitate versus delayed therapy in high risk patients. Further economic benefits may be realised by the sequential use of antenatal corticosteroids and surfactant therapy, although this has yet to be prospectively investigated. In conclusion, clinical and pharmacoeconomic data strongly support the use of rescue therapy with colfosceril palmitate. Additionally, recent clinical data indicating that even better results may be achieved with earlier administration and/or combined use with antenatal corticosteroids should be assessed from an economic standpoint to determine the optimal prescribing strategy for this agent.
综合临床数据有力证明了合成肺表面活性物质棕榈酰可尔氟(固尔苏)在预防或抢救治疗呼吸窘迫综合征(RDS)婴儿时的有效性。成本效益分析进一步支持了使用棕榈酰可尔氟进行抢救治疗,这些分析报告显示,与安慰剂或历史对照相比,每名存活者的成本降低了9%至48%,尽管研究方法有差异且属于不同地区。重要的是,无论是较大(≥1250克)还是较小(700至1350克)的婴儿,都能明显节省成本。所有研究均考虑了从住院初期到1岁期间产生的成本或费用;为了进行更全面的药物经济学评估,需要测量长期资源使用数据以及所有由此产生的成本。鉴于一项大型国际试验的疗效数据支持在高危患者中尽早使用棕榈酰可尔氟而非延迟治疗,表面活性物质给药的最佳时机可能是一个重要的经济问题。序贯使用产前皮质类固醇和表面活性物质治疗可能会带来更多经济效益,不过这还有待前瞻性研究。总之,临床和药物经济学数据有力支持使用棕榈酰可尔氟进行抢救治疗。此外,最近的临床数据表明,更早给药和/或与产前皮质类固醇联合使用可能会取得更好的效果,应从经济学角度对此进行评估,以确定该药物最佳的处方策略。