Kent P J, Weston M J
Department of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, St James's University Hospital, Leeds.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1998 Nov;80(6):388-93.
Reflux was assessed using hand-held Doppler (HHD) and duplex scanning in 72 patients with primary, previously untreated varicose veins (108 limbs). The aims of the study were (i) to compare the accuracy of HHD assessment with duplex scanning, (ii) to assess the benefit of tourniquet testing and (iii) to identify patients who would benefit from a policy of selective duplex scanning. HHD accurately assesses the saphenofemoral junction (SFJ) and long saphenous vein (LSV) reflux. HHD assessment of the saphenopopliteal junction (SPJ) reflux has a low positive predictive value. A high negative predictive value reflects absent SPJ reflux assessed using HHD accurately. Tourniquet testing is not helpful. Selective duplex scanning of limbs with suspected SPJ reflux, no identifiable site of reflux or posterior thigh perforator reflux on HDD (39% of limbs), would result in the appropriate surgical procedure being performed in 102 (94%) limbs, excessive surgery in 5 (5%) limbs and inadequate surgery in only 1 (1%) limb. The use of selective criteria for duplex scanning would reduce the workload of the vascular laboratory without compromising patient care.
在72例原发性、未经治疗的静脉曲张患者(108条肢体)中,使用手持多普勒(HHD)和双功超声扫描评估反流情况。本研究的目的是:(i)比较HHD评估与双功超声扫描的准确性;(ii)评估止血带试验的益处;(iii)确定从选择性双功超声扫描策略中获益的患者。HHD能准确评估大隐静脉股静脉交界处(SFJ)和大隐静脉(LSV)反流情况。HHD对大隐静脉腘静脉交界处(SPJ)反流的评估具有较低的阳性预测值。较高的阴性预测值反映出使用HHD准确评估时SPJ反流不存在。止血带试验并无帮助。对HHD检查怀疑存在SPJ反流、未发现反流部位或大腿后侧穿支反流的肢体(占肢体的39%)进行选择性双功超声扫描,将使102条(94%)肢体接受适当的手术治疗,5条(5%)肢体手术过度,仅1条(1%)肢体手术不足。使用选择性标准进行双功超声扫描可减少血管实验室的工作量,且不影响患者护理。