Durham M L, Pierce G L
Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci. 1986 Mar(484):42-55.
Recent legal changes in Washington State have broadened the grave-disability criterion for civil commitment of the mentally ill. Analysis of data from state mental hospitals and from records of commitment authorities in Washington's two largest counties revealed that, while there was an increase in the number of involuntary hospitalizations immediately before and after the changes in law, there was a virtual disappearance of voluntary patients in state hospitals. Moreover, expansion of the definition of "grave disability" resulted in a move toward a parens patriae-dominated civil commitment system. Analysis of the empirical consequences of the legal changes on commitment decisions is presented, along with the response of mental health officials and the public.
华盛顿州最近的法律变更拓宽了对精神病患者进行民事收押的严重残疾标准。对该州精神病院的数据以及华盛顿州两个最大县的收押机构记录进行分析后发现,虽然在法律变更前后非自愿住院人数有所增加,但州立医院的自愿住院患者实际上消失了。此外,“严重残疾”定义的扩大导致了向国家监护主导的民事收押系统的转变。本文呈现了法律变更对收押决定的实证影响分析,以及心理健康官员和公众的反应。