Development, evolution, and corroboration.

The cloning of genes involved in pathways fundamental to morphogenesis has opened the door to visualizing expression of developmental regulatory genes in many organisms. Expression data have become technical commonplace in analysis of mutants of Drosophila melanogaster and a handful of other genetic model systems. Many researchers have used probes and extended the logic from studies of D. melanogaster for comparisons of expression patterns to infer developmental bases for homologous structures among animals with diverse body plans. This research program has led to exciting but sweeping generalizations about how development evolves. Here we examine several underlying assumptions of this approach in terms of comparative and historical biology. First, we evaluate the logic that underlies the equation of gene expression similarity with homologous morphology. Second, we examine epistemological issues surrounding the descriptive visualization of gene expression patterns. We conclude by examining the role of phylogenetic coding and mapping of these patterns to examine the evolution of complex gene regulatory networks.