Thompson D, Snape E, Stokes C
Department of Management, Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
Int J Health Plann Manage. 1999 Jan-Mar;14(1):19-39. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1099-1751(199901/03)14:1<19::AID-HPM533>3.0.CO;2-M.
This article discusses the empirical study of reform in the human resource management function in the Hong Kong Hospital Authority. It describes the prior management of the hospitals based on the civil service administration model before looking at management reform in general. From this research, the creative tensions between the centrifugal and centripetal forces in the pursuit of 'effectiveness', 'efficiency' and 'economy' are explored in terms of decentralization. A survey of line managers, in eleven Hospital Authority hospitals, revealed the progress of decentralization: a majority of respondents felt that, over the previous five years, managers at their level had been given greater responsibility for human resource management issues. In spite of the widespread perception of increased decentralization, however, it was recognized that there are limits to decentralization. It was the routine administration rather than the policy formulation and interpretation which had been decentralized, and hospitals continued to rely on the Hospital Authority Head of Office for guidance on policy interpretation. Several barriers to the effective decentralization of responsibility for human resource management were identified, including a lack of management skill, knowledge and time, the attitudes of some managers and the tight control of budget.
本文探讨了香港医院管理局人力资源管理职能改革的实证研究。在总体审视管理改革之前,它描述了基于公务员行政模式的医院先前管理情况。通过这项研究,从分权角度探讨了在追求“有效性”“效率”和“经济性”过程中离心力和向心力之间的创造性张力。对医院管理局11家医院的一线管理人员进行的一项调查揭示了分权的进展情况:大多数受访者认为,在过去五年里,他们这个层级的管理人员在人力资源管理问题上被赋予了更大的责任。然而,尽管普遍认为分权有所增加,但人们认识到分权是有限度的。被下放的是日常行政管理工作,而非政策制定和解释工作,医院在政策解释方面仍依赖医院管理局总办事处主任提供指导。研究确定了有效下放人力资源管理责任的若干障碍,包括缺乏管理技能、知识和时间,一些管理人员的态度以及对预算的严格控制。