Rathmann W, Haastert B, Giani G
Abteilung Biometrie und Epidemiologie, Diabetes Forschungsinstitut an der Heinrich Heine Universität Düsseldorf.
Dtsch Med Wochenschr. 1999 Jun 4;124(22):681-6. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-1024397.
Numerous medications are used in the treatment of diabetic polyneuropathy (PNP) without evidence of their efficacy. This study was undertaken to obtain the costs of drugs prescribed to patients with PNP throughout the Federal Republic of Germany in primary-care practices.
Data (stored in the Medi-Plus data bank of the Institute for Medical Statistics, Frankfurt) from 400 primary-care practices were analysed for the year 1996 with regard to diagnoses and prescriptions for 40,112 diabetics over the age of > or = 20 years. A polyneuropathy (PNP) had been diagnosed in 3548 patients (8.8%) (age: 68 +/- 12 years, 56% women). The cost of medications listed for the treatment of PNP was identified and extrapolated to the total prescription cost for treated diabetic PNP in the whole of Germany. In addition the proportion of costs for drugs with unproven efficacy was calculated.
Antidepressives were prescribed for 13%, carbamazepine for 4%, and lipoic (thioctic) acid for 41% of diabetics with PNP. Annual costs per patient (mean value) were DM 203 for lipoic acid, DM 53 for vasoactive drugs and DM 42 for analgesics. Projection for the estimated total number of diabetic patients with PNP treated in primary care practices (n = 361,400) gave a total cost of DM 116 million (95% confidence limit: DM 109-123), of which DM 41 million (35%) was for medications of unproven efficacy.
In Germany one third of drug costs for diabetic patients with PNP in primary care is for medications of unproven efficacy. Cost-effective guidelines for the treatment of diabetic PNP are urgently required.
众多药物被用于治疗糖尿病性多发性神经病(PNP),但其疗效尚无证据支持。本研究旨在获取德国联邦共和国基层医疗实践中为PNP患者开具药物的费用情况。
分析了来自400家基层医疗实践的数据(存储于法兰克福医学统计研究所的Medi-Plus数据库),这些数据涉及1996年40112名年龄≥20岁的糖尿病患者的诊断和处方情况。3548名患者(8.8%)被诊断为多发性神经病(PNP)(年龄:68±12岁,56%为女性)。确定了列出的用于治疗PNP的药物费用,并推算出德国全国治疗糖尿病性PNP的处方总费用。此外,还计算了疗效未经证实的药物费用所占比例。
在患有PNP的糖尿病患者中,13%的患者开具了抗抑郁药,4%的患者开具了卡马西平,41%的患者开具了硫辛酸。硫辛酸每位患者的年费用(平均值)为203德国马克,血管活性药物为53德国马克,镇痛药为42德国马克。对基层医疗实践中接受治疗的糖尿病性PNP患者估计总数(n = 361400)的预测显示,总费用为1.16亿德国马克(95%置信区间:1.09 - 1.23亿德国马克),其中4100万德国马克(35%)用于疗效未经证实的药物。
在德国,基层医疗中糖尿病性PNP患者的药物费用有三分之一用于疗效未经证实的药物。迫切需要制定具有成本效益的糖尿病性PNP治疗指南。