Risser W L, Gefter L R, Barratt M S, Risser J M
Department of Pediatrics and School of Public Health, University of Texas-Houston Health Sciences Center, USA.
J Adolesc Health. 1999 Jun;24(6):433-6. doi: 10.1016/s1054-139x(98)00151-7.
(a) To compare weight change at 1 year between adolescents 13-19 years old who were using either depot medroxyprogesterone acetate (DMPA) or oral contraceptives (OC), and (b) to determine if age, baseline body mass index (BMI), race/ethnicity, or weight gain at 3 months predicted which subjects would gain excessive weight.
The setting was a Planned Parenthood Teen Clinic with chart review of variables of interest. Excessive weight was defined as weight gain > 10%.
Baseline variables were similar in the two groups, except that DMPA users (n = 44) had a greater mean BMI (t test, p = .05) than OC users (n = 86). Mean (standard deviation) and median weight gains at 1 year were 3.0 (4.5) and 2.4 kg in the DMPA users and 1.3 (3.9) and 1.5 kg in the OC users (difference in medians not significant, Wilcoxon rank sum test, p = .10). Fifty-six percent of DMPA and 70% of OC users lost weight or gained < 5% of their baseline weight (p = .17, Fisher exact test); 25% of DMPA users and 7% of OC users gained > 10% of their baseline weight (p = .006). Age, baseline BMI, or race/ethnicity did not affect the likelihood that either group would gain > 5% or > 10% of their baseline weight. Of adolescents who gained > 5% of baseline weight at 3 months, 13 of 14 (93%) gained even more weight at 12 months.
The majority of adolescents who used hormonal contraception for 1 year lost weight or gained < 5% of baseline weight. DMPA users were more likely than OC users to gain > 10%. Subjects who gained > 5% of baseline weight at 3 months were at high risk (93%) of gaining even more weight by 1 year.
(a)比较13 - 19岁使用醋酸甲羟孕酮长效避孕针(DMPA)或口服避孕药(OC)的青少年在1年时的体重变化,(b)确定年龄、基线体重指数(BMI)、种族/族裔或3个月时的体重增加是否能预测哪些受试者会体重过度增加。
研究地点为计划生育青少年诊所,对感兴趣的变量进行病历审查。体重过度增加定义为体重增加>10%。
两组的基线变量相似,不过DMPA使用者(n = 44)的平均BMI高于OC使用者(n = 86)(t检验,p = 0.05)。DMPA使用者1年时的平均(标准差)和中位数体重增加分别为3.0(4.5)kg和2.4 kg,OC使用者分别为1.3(3.9)kg和1.5 kg(中位数差异不显著,Wilcoxon秩和检验,p = 0.10)。56%的DMPA使用者和70%的OC使用者体重减轻或体重增加<基线体重的5%(p = 0.17,Fisher精确检验);25%的DMPA使用者和7%的OC使用者体重增加>基线体重的10%(p = 0.006)。年龄、基线BMI或种族/族裔并不影响两组中任何一组体重增加>基线体重5%或10%的可能性。在3个月时体重增加>基线体重5%的青少年中,14人中有13人(93%)在12个月时体重增加更多。
大多数使用激素避孕1年的青少年体重减轻或体重增加<基线体重的5%。DMPA使用者比OC使用者更有可能体重增加>10%。在3个月时体重增加>基线体重5%的受试者在1年时体重进一步增加的风险很高(93%)。