Roos L L, Traverse D, Turner D
Department of Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada.
Med Care. 1999 Jun;37(6 Suppl):JS264-78. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199906001-00020.
A successful program of prevention or early detection should have a high level of population coverage and should ensure that high-risk populations are targeted. In practice, relatively little attention has been paid to the tendency toward greater use of preventive care by populations at lower risk, in other words, for higher use by the wealthy than by the poor. Current delivery patterns of preventive care raise questions as to how to organize these services more effectively. Physician-based delivery of preventive care in a fee-for-service system seems to result in Canadian patterns of use that are fairly similar to those found in the United States. Universal free insurance alone does not appear to be enough to counteract the failure to target preventive care toward the least-healthy groups. Appropriately-run Canadian provincial programs may be able both to expand coverage and to target high-risk populations. The population coverage for three measures directed toward prevention or early detection--childhood immunization (which in Manitoba has been offered through a long-standing provincial program), screening mammography (a new provincial program), and cervical cancer screening (no provincial program)-are compared using longitudinal administrative data from Manitoba. The discussion emphasizes the role of provincial programs and the possibilities for using population-based data to help provide cost-effective care to high-risk populations.
一个成功的预防或早期检测项目应具备较高的人群覆盖率,并确保针对高风险人群。实际上,相对较少有人关注低风险人群更多使用预防性护理的趋势,换句话说,即富人比穷人更多地使用预防性护理。当前预防性护理的提供模式引发了关于如何更有效地组织这些服务的问题。在按服务收费系统中,基于医生提供预防性护理似乎导致加拿大的使用模式与美国的模式相当相似。仅靠全民免费保险似乎不足以抵消未能将预防性护理针对最不健康群体的问题。管理得当的加拿大省级项目或许既能扩大覆盖范围,又能针对高风险人群。利用来自曼尼托巴省的纵向行政数据,对针对预防或早期检测的三项措施——儿童免疫接种(在曼尼托巴省通过一个长期的省级项目提供)、乳腺钼靶筛查(一个新的省级项目)和宫颈癌筛查(无省级项目)——的人群覆盖率进行了比较。讨论强调了省级项目的作用以及利用基于人群的数据来帮助为高风险人群提供具有成本效益的护理的可能性。