Fowler E, MacRae S, Stern A, Harrison T, Gerteis M, Walker J, Edgman-Levitan S, Ruga W
Department of Institutional Research, University of Massachusetts at Dartmouth, USA.
Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1999 Jul;25(7):352-62. doi: 10.1016/s1070-3241(16)30450-3.
Although there has been little systematic assessment of how the built environment of health care facilities affects the quality of care, the built environment is a major element of structure of care--one of three facets of quality. Yet in contrast to the growing trend of using consumer perceptions of both processes and outcomes of care in QI activities, quality assessments of the structure of care do not currently rely on patient feedback. PURPOSE OF PROJECT: During the initial phase of a multiphase project, nine focus groups were conducted in 1997 to identify the salient dimensions of experience from the patient's perspective. The content of these focus groups guided the development of assessment tools in the second phase of the project, which began in February 1998.
Participants in three focus groups that were held in each of three settings--ambulatory care, acute care, and long term care--described in detail a variety of reactions to the built environment. Analysis revealed eight consistent themes in what patients and family member consumers look for in the built environment of health care. In all three settings, they want an environment, for example, that facilitates a connection to staff and caregivers, is conducive to a sense of well-being, and facilitates a connection to the outside world.
Data derived from the focus group research has guided the development of quantitative survey and assessment tools. For each setting, patient-centered checklists and questionnaires are designed to help institutions set priorities for the improvement of facility design from the patient's perspective.
尽管对于医疗保健设施的建筑环境如何影响护理质量几乎没有系统的评估,但建筑环境是护理结构的一个主要要素——护理质量的三个方面之一。然而,与在质量改进活动中越来越多地使用消费者对护理过程和结果的看法的趋势形成对比的是,目前护理结构的质量评估并不依赖于患者反馈。项目目的:在一个多阶段项目的初始阶段,1997年开展了9个焦点小组,从患者的角度确定体验的显著维度。这些焦点小组的内容指导了该项目第二阶段评估工具的开发,该阶段于1998年2月开始。
在门诊护理、急性护理和长期护理这三种环境中分别举行的三个焦点小组的参与者详细描述了对建筑环境的各种反应。分析揭示了患者和家庭成员消费者在医疗保健建筑环境中所期望的八个一致主题。在所有这三种环境中,例如,他们希望有一个便于与工作人员和护理人员建立联系、有助于产生幸福感并便于与外部世界建立联系的环境。
焦点小组研究得出的数据指导了定量调查和评估工具的开发。针对每种环境,设计了以患者为中心的清单和问卷,以帮助机构从患者的角度确定设施设计改进的优先事项。