Verleyen P, De Ridder D, Van Poppel H, Baert L
Service of Urology, University Hospitals Leuven, Belgium.
Eur Urol. 1999 Sep;36(3):240-6. doi: 10.1159/000068005.
We performed two randomized prospective studies with the silver-coated Bardex IC catheter in order to evaluate the incidence of bacteriuria during short- and medium-term catheterization after urological procedures.
During catheterization only consecutive suprapubic urine samples were taken and cultured. After removal of the catheter the patient was allowed one wash-out void, and before the second micturition a suprapubic puncture was performed to collect a culture specimen.
In the first trial, after radical prostatectomy 18 patients with the Bardex IC catheter were compared to 17 patients with a silicon catheter after the same procedure. There was no significant difference in bacteriuria after 14 days (50.0 vs. 53.3%). In the second part of the study 180 patients were evaluated 101 with latex and 79 with Bardex IC catheters. The median catheterization time was 5 days. The results show a significant delay in the onset of bacteriuria when a silver alloy catheter is used (p < 0.003). On day 5 only 6.3% had bacteriuria in the Bardex IC group versus 11.9% in the latex group.
We conclude that, after urological procedures, short-term catheterization with the Bardex IC catheter is superior to the classical latex catheter.
我们使用涂银的巴德克斯IC导管进行了两项随机前瞻性研究,以评估泌尿外科手术后短期和中期导尿期间菌尿症的发生率。
导尿期间仅采集连续的耻骨上尿液样本并进行培养。拔除导管后,允许患者进行一次冲洗排尿,在第二次排尿前进行耻骨上穿刺以采集培养标本。
在第一项试验中,将18例接受巴德克斯IC导管的前列腺癌根治术后患者与17例接受相同手术的硅胶导管患者进行比较。14天后菌尿症发生率无显著差异(50.0%对53.3%)。在研究的第二部分,对180例患者进行了评估,其中101例使用乳胶导管,79例使用巴德克斯IC导管。导尿的中位时间为5天。结果显示,使用银合金导管时菌尿症的发作有显著延迟(p<0.003)。在第5天,巴德克斯IC组只有6.3%的患者发生菌尿症,而乳胶组为11.9%。
我们得出结论,在泌尿外科手术后,使用巴德克斯IC导管进行短期导尿优于传统的乳胶导管。