Gueyffier F, Bulpitt C, Boissel J P, Schron E, Ekbom T, Fagard R, Casiglia E, Kerlikowske K, Coope J
Clinical Pharmacology Department, Claude Bernard University, Lyon Hospitals, France.
Lancet. 1999 Mar 6;353(9155):793-6. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(98)08127-6.
Beneficial clinical effects of treatment with antihypertensive drugs have been shown in middle-aged patients and in those hypertensive patients over 60 years old, but whether treatment is beneficial in patients over 80 years old is not known.
We collected data from all participants aged 80 years and over in randomised controlled trials of antihypertensive drugs through direct contact with study investigators. Our primary outcome was fatal and non-fatal stroke. Secondary outcomes were death from all causes, cardiovascular death, fatal and non-fatal major coronary and cardiovascular events, and heart failure.
There were 57 strokes and 34 deaths among 874 actively treated patients, compared with 77 strokes and 28 stroke deaths among 796 controls, representing 1 non-fatal stroke prevented for about 100 patients treated each year. The meta-analysis of data from 1670 participants aged 80 years or older suggested that treatment prevented 34% (95% CI 8-52) of strokes. Rates of major cardiovascular events and heart failure were significantly decreased, by 22% and 39%, respectively. However, there was no treatment benefit for cardiovascular death, and a non-significant 6% (-5 to 18) relative excess of death from all causes.
The inconclusive findings for mortality contrast with the benefit of treatment for non-fatal events. Results of a large-scale specific trial are needed for definite conclusion that antihypertensive treatment is beneficial in very elderly hypertensive patients. Meanwhile, an age threshold beyond which hypertension should not be treated cannot be justified.
抗高血压药物治疗已在中年患者及60岁以上高血压患者中显示出有益的临床效果,但对于80岁以上患者治疗是否有益尚不清楚。
我们通过直接与研究调查人员联系,收集了抗高血压药物随机对照试验中所有80岁及以上参与者的数据。我们的主要结局是致命和非致命性中风。次要结局是全因死亡、心血管死亡、致命和非致命性主要冠状动脉和心血管事件以及心力衰竭。
874名积极治疗的患者中有57例中风和34例死亡,而796名对照组中有77例中风和28例中风死亡,这意味着每年约100名接受治疗的患者可预防1例非致命性中风。对1670名80岁及以上参与者的数据进行的荟萃分析表明,治疗可预防34%(95%CI 8-52)的中风。主要心血管事件和心力衰竭的发生率分别显著降低了22%和39%。然而,治疗对心血管死亡没有益处,全因死亡相对增加了6%(-5至18),但无统计学意义。
死亡率方面的不确定结果与非致命事件治疗的益处形成对比。需要大规模特定试验的结果才能明确得出抗高血压治疗对非常老年高血压患者有益的结论。同时,无法证明存在一个不应治疗高血压的年龄阈值。