Kloster R, Engelskjøn T
The National Center for Epilepsy, Sandvika, Norway.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1999 Oct;67(4):439-44. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.67.4.439.
To examine the risk factors and their relative importance and possible role in sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP).
The study was conducted as a retrospective analysis of deaths in an outpatient population of a tertiary referral centre, based on clinical and pathological data.
Of a total of 140 deaths, 61 (44%) had not been to postmortem and were excluded, 37 (26%) had a verified cause of death and formed the non-SUDEP group, and 42 (30%) were classified as SUDEP. In the SUDEP group there was pulmonary oedema in 62%, signs of preceding seizures in 67%, no visible seizures in three of six observed deaths. A high seizure frequency prevailed in SUDEP as well as non-SUDEP. Sixty per cent of deaths were sleep related. Various other circumstances were temporally associated with death. The prone position at death was seen in 71% of the SUDEP patients; possible interpretations are discussed. Supposedly subtherapeutic serum concentrations of one or more antiepileptic drugs were found in 57% of those with reported serum concentrations. Alcohol was not a factor in the material, whereas hyponatraemia was seen in two cases.
Most cases of SUDEP are preceded by seizures; their presence, frequency, type, aetiology, tractability, and the use of antiepileptic drugs are factors in the demise. No common risk factor, present in all cases of SUDEP, could be found, suggesting the probability of multiple mechanisms behind SUDEP.
研究癫痫性猝死(SUDEP)的危险因素、它们的相对重要性以及在SUDEP中可能发挥的作用。
本研究是基于临床和病理数据,对一家三级转诊中心门诊患者的死亡情况进行回顾性分析。
在总共140例死亡病例中,61例(44%)未进行尸检而被排除,37例(26%)有明确的死亡原因,构成非SUDEP组,42例(30%)被归类为SUDEP。在SUDEP组中,62%有肺水肿,67%有癫痫发作前驱症状,在观察的6例死亡中有3例未观察到明显的癫痫发作。SUDEP组和非SUDEP组癫痫发作频率均较高。60%的死亡与睡眠有关。其他各种情况在时间上与死亡相关。71%的SUDEP患者死亡时呈俯卧位;对可能的解释进行了讨论。在报告血清浓度的患者中,57%发现一种或多种抗癫痫药物的血清浓度可能低于治疗水平。材料中酒精不是一个因素,而低钠血症在2例中出现。
大多数SUDEP病例之前有癫痫发作;癫痫发作的存在、频率、类型、病因、可治疗性以及抗癫痫药物的使用都是导致死亡的因素。未发现所有SUDEP病例都存在的共同危险因素,这表明SUDEP背后可能存在多种机制。