Dykstra P A, de Jong Gierveld J
Nederlands Interdisciplinair Demografisch Instituut, Den Haag.
Tijdschr Gerontol Geriatr. 1999 Oct;30(5):212-25.
Using data from the 1992 NESTOR-survey 'Living arrangements and social networks of older adults' (N = 4494), the aim of the present study is to identify specific categories of older adults who are most vulnerable to loneliness. By looking at different types of partner relationships (first, second, and third marriages; consensual unions; partners who are not household members) and at partner histories (never married, ever divorced, ever widowed, remarried), this study elaborates on previous research which has tended to look only at the presence versus the absence of partner relationships. Findings indicate that different types of partner relationships provide differential protection against loneliness. There appears to be a 'shadow of the past' of a previous divorce or widowhood in second and third partnerships, which accounts for generally higher levels of loneliness. Single men tend to be more lonely than single women. Moreover, there are no differences in loneliness between men who have always been single and those previously married. Among single women, differences in partner history are relevant: never married single women tend to be least vulnerable to loneliness. The differences in loneliness between older adults with different types of partner relationships and partner histories are only partially attributable to network and social participation differences. The latter independently contribute to the explanation of loneliness. The role of non-social determinants (health and socioeconomic position) is also examined. The results underscore the socially isolating effects of sensory impairments. Older adults with functional limitations, and those with visual or auditory problems tend to be more lonely, findings which are only partially attributable to differences in the number and quality of social relationships. Socioeconomic circumstances primarily have an indirect influence on loneliness. Those with higher levels of educational attainment and higher incomes tend to have more extensive social networks and are therefore less prone to loneliness.
本研究利用1992年“老年人的生活安排和社会网络”NESTOR调查(N = 4494)的数据,旨在确定最易感到孤独的老年人的特定类别。通过考察不同类型的伴侣关系(初婚、二婚和三婚;事实婚姻;非家庭成员伴侣)以及伴侣经历(从未结婚、曾经离婚、曾经丧偶、再婚),本研究对以往往往只关注伴侣关系存在与否的研究进行了详细阐述。研究结果表明,不同类型的伴侣关系对孤独感提供了不同程度的保护。在二婚和三婚关系中,似乎存在着先前离婚或丧偶的“过去阴影”,这导致总体孤独感水平较高。单身男性往往比单身女性更孤独。此外,一直单身的男性和曾经结婚的男性在孤独感方面没有差异。在单身女性中,伴侣经历的差异是相关的:从未结婚的单身女性往往最不易感到孤独。不同类型伴侣关系和伴侣经历的老年人在孤独感上的差异,只有部分可归因于社交网络和社会参与的差异。后者独立地有助于解释孤独感。还考察了非社会决定因素(健康和社会经济地位)的作用。结果强调了感官障碍的社会隔离效应。有功能限制的老年人以及有视觉或听觉问题的老年人往往更孤独,这些发现只有部分可归因于社会关系数量和质量的差异。社会经济状况主要对孤独感有间接影响。受教育程度较高和收入较高的人往往有更广泛的社会网络,因此不太容易感到孤独。