Hayes M W, Graham S, Heldorf P, de Moore G, Morris J G
Department of Neurology, Westmead Hospital, NSW, Australia.
Mov Disord. 1999 Nov;14(6):914-21. doi: 10.1002/1531-8257(199911)14:6<914::aid-mds1002>3.0.co;2-b.
The gait and other clinical features of 22 patients presenting to our hospital over the last 10 years are shown on video. In 12 patients, a diagnosis of psychogenic gait was made; in the remainder, the gait abnormality was the result of a neurologic disease. Psychogenic gaits are compared and contrasted with "organic" gaits. In one patient, the psychogenic gait occurred in the setting of a neurologic disease. The "traditional" approach to psychogenic gait, attempting to exclude underlying neurologic and psychiatric disease and seeking evidence for primary and secondary gain, was found to be of limited value. More useful were the features of the gait itself, in particular, exaggerated effort, extreme slowness, variability throughout the day, unusual or uneconomic postures, collapses, convulsive tremors, and distractibility; certain aspects of the history were also helpful. A list of comments is provided. The diagnosis of psychogenic gait, particularly in the elderly, remains fraught with hazard, and a balance has to be sought between subjecting an anxious patient to needless investigations and yet not losing sight of the fact that the patient may be elaborating on symptoms of genuine disease. The bizarre gait of some neurologic disorders, particularly dystonia and chorea, may be a pitfall for the unwary.
视频展示了过去10年里到我院就诊的22例患者的步态及其他临床特征。其中12例被诊断为精神源性步态;其余患者的步态异常是由神经系统疾病导致的。对精神源性步态与“器质性”步态进行了比较和对比。有1例患者的精神源性步态出现在神经系统疾病背景下。发现试图排除潜在神经和精神疾病并寻找原发性和继发性获益证据的“传统”精神源性步态诊断方法价值有限。步态本身的特征更具诊断价值,特别是用力过度、极度缓慢、全天变化不定、姿势异常或不经济、跌倒、抽搐性震颤和易分散注意力;病史的某些方面也有帮助。文中提供了一系列评论。精神源性步态的诊断,尤其是在老年人中,仍然充满风险,必须在让焦虑的患者接受不必要检查和不忽视患者可能夸大真正疾病症状这两者之间寻求平衡。一些神经系统疾病,特别是肌张力障碍和舞蹈病的怪异步态,可能会给粗心者带来陷阱。