Role of surgical residents in undergraduate surgical education.

OBJECTIVES

To identify the role and impact of surgical residents on the various activities of a senior (4th year) surgical clerkship, and to explore students' perceptions of differences between the teaching behaviours of attending physicians and residents.

DESIGN

A survey by questionnaire.

SETTING

McGill University, Montreal.

METHOD

A 67-item questionnaire was administered to fourth-year medical students at the end of their 8-week surgical clerkship. Analysis of the data was performed using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test, Dunn's multiple comparison test and mean average.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Overall satisfaction with the clerkship, teaching behaviours and teaching of clinical skills and basic principles.

RESULTS

Overall satisfaction with the clerkship was 6.31 out of 10. Surgical residents were perceived as being significantly more active than the attending staff in 14 out of 15 teaching behaviours. They were also seen as important in teaching certain clinical skills such as suturing, assisting in the operating room and managing emergency situations. They also contributed significantly to teaching the basic principles of surgery such as infections, surgical bleeding and fluid and electrolytes. On a 10-point scale, students felt that more learning was achieved by independent reading, tutorials and residents' teaching than by other teaching modalities, including attending physicians' and nurses' teaching.

CONCLUSIONS

Medical students perceive surgical residents as being significantly more active in their education process than the attending staff. Residents appear to be responsible for teaching various technical and patient management skills necessary for patient care. Along with independent reading and tutorials, resident teaching contributes a significant portion of the medical student's acquisition of knowledge and appears to contribute to the students' choice of surgery as a career.