Costa P, Papurel Begin G, Coaloa M, Villa C, Ravera E, Hellmann F, Di Giovanni M, Bono D
Servizio di Anestesia e Rianimazione, Ospedale SS. Annunziata, Savigliano, Cuneo.
Minerva Anestesiol. 1999 Nov;65(11):775-83.
The aim of this study is the comparison between the use of bupivacaine alone and a mixture of bupivacaine, mepivacaine and hyaluronidase in both retrobulbar and peribulbar blockades for eye surgery. Three hundred ninety-nine consecutive adult patients scheduled for cataract surgery with regional anaesthesia were included in this prospective, randomized and partially blind study. Peribulbar blockade was performed on 199 patients (group P). Ninety-nine of them received a mixture of local anaesthetics and hyaluronidase (sub-group M), while 100 received bupivacaine alone (sub-group B). Retrobulbar blockade was performed on 200 patients (group R): 100 of them received the mixture with hyaluronidase (sub-group M), while 100 received bupivacaine (sub-group B). The interval between anaesthesia and motor blockade (onset time), the presence of residual ocular movements, the need of further anaesthesia, the quality of anaesthesia, the ocular tone, the length of anaesthesia and possible complications were registered.
Retrobulbar blockade has the only advantage of a shorter onset time, while peribulbar blockade shows a longer anaesthetic effect. Mixture with hyaluronidase (the sub-group M) has a shorter onset time, a lesser need of further anaesthesia, fewer residual ocular movements and a better quality of anaesthesia.
Local anaesthetics mixture with hyaluronidase associated with peribulbar blockade presents the advantages of rapidity, duration and better quality without the risks of retrobulbar blockade side effects.
本研究的目的是比较单纯使用布比卡因与布比卡因、甲哌卡因和透明质酸酶的混合物在眼科手术球后阻滞和球周阻滞中的应用。本前瞻性、随机且部分盲法研究纳入了399例计划接受区域麻醉白内障手术的连续成年患者。对199例患者进行球周阻滞(P组)。其中99例接受局部麻醉药与透明质酸酶的混合物(M亚组),而100例仅接受布比卡因(B亚组)。对200例患者进行球后阻滞(R组):其中100例接受含透明质酸酶的混合物(M亚组),而100例接受布比卡因(B亚组)。记录麻醉与运动阻滞之间的间隔时间(起效时间)、残余眼球运动情况、是否需要追加麻醉、麻醉质量、眼压、麻醉时长及可能的并发症。
球后阻滞唯一的优点是起效时间较短,而球周阻滞的麻醉效果持续时间更长。与透明质酸酶混合(M亚组)起效时间更短,追加麻醉的需求更少,残余眼球运动更少,麻醉质量更好。
局部麻醉药与透明质酸酶混合用于球周阻滞具有起效快、持续时间长和质量更好的优点,且无球后阻滞副作用风险。