Greenberg R, Haddad R, Kashtan H, Kaplan O
Department of Surgery A, Tel-Aviv Sourasky Medical Center and the Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel-Aviv University, Israel.
J Lab Clin Med. 2000 Feb;135(2):112-21. doi: 10.1067/mlc.2000.104457.
The role of somatostatin and octreotide for AP has been studied for two decades, yet the data still remain inconclusive. The inconsistencies of the results of experimental studies and clinical trials may stem from the fact that the optimal therapeutic modality has not been determined. Furthermore, although they are similar in structure and physiologic activities, the mechanisms of action and effects of somatostatin and octreotide in AP may be different. Because the data are sparse, most reports, primarily those in the English literature, on the efficacy of somatostatin and octreotide in the management of AP were reviewed. Included are both nonrandomized and prospective, double-blind, clinical trials and studies on the effects of these agents on various experimental models of the disease. The results of the studies on somatostatin and octreotide are presented and discussed separately, with specific reference to the experimental and treatment details. The main focus of the review is the effect of subcutaneous and intravenous administration of octreotide. Analysis of the data suggests that somatostatin could not be recommended for AP and that the efficacy of subcutaneous administration of octreotide is also questionable. Theoretically, intravenous octreotide may be more appropriate for this condition, but recent results with this therapeutic method are limited and contradictory. Studies that would delineate the optimal therapeutical modality and the patient population most likely to respond to the treatment are prerequisite for large-scale clinical trials on the effects of octreotide on human pancreatitis.
生长抑素和奥曲肽在急性胰腺炎(AP)中的作用已研究了二十年,但数据仍无定论。实验研究和临床试验结果的不一致可能源于尚未确定最佳治疗方式这一事实。此外,尽管生长抑素和奥曲肽在结构和生理活性上相似,但它们在AP中的作用机制和效果可能不同。由于数据稀少,我们回顾了大多数关于生长抑素和奥曲肽治疗AP疗效的报告,主要是英文文献中的报告。这些报告包括非随机和前瞻性、双盲临床试验以及关于这些药物对该疾病各种实验模型影响的研究。分别介绍和讨论了关于生长抑素和奥曲肽的研究结果,并特别提及了实验和治疗细节。综述的主要重点是皮下和静脉注射奥曲肽的效果。数据分析表明,不推荐将生长抑素用于AP,皮下注射奥曲肽的疗效也值得怀疑。理论上,静脉注射奥曲肽可能更适合这种情况,但这种治疗方法的最新结果有限且相互矛盾。明确最佳治疗方式以及最可能对治疗有反应的患者群体的研究,是关于奥曲肽对人类胰腺炎影响的大规模临床试验的先决条件。