Kuhl C K, Schmutzler R K, Leutner C C, Kempe A, Wardelmann E, Hocke A, Maringa M, Pfeifer U, Krebs D, Schild H H
Departments of Radiology, University of Bonn Medical Center, Sigmund-Freud-Strasse 25, D-53105 Bonn, Germany.
Radiology. 2000 Apr;215(1):267-79. doi: 10.1148/radiology.215.1.r00ap01267.
To compare magnetic resonance (MR) imaging with conventional imaging in screening high-risk women.
This prospective trial included 192 asymptomatic and six symptomatic women who, on the basis of personal or family history or genetic analysis, were suspected or proved to carry a breast cancer susceptibility gene.
Fifteen breast cancers were identified: nine in the 192 asymptomatic women (six in the first and three in the second screening round) and six in the symptomatic patients. Concerning the asymptomatic women, four of the nine breast cancers were detected and correctly classified with mammography and ultrasonography (US) combined; another two cancers were visible as well-circumscribed masses and were diagnosed as fibroadenomas. MR imaging allowed the correct classification and local staging of all nine cancers. In 105 asymptomatic women with validation of the 1st-year screening results, the sensitivities of mammography, US, and MR imaging were 33%, 33% (mammography and US combined, 44%), and 100%, respectively; the positive predictive values were 30%, 12%, and 64%, respectively.
The accuracy of MR imaging is significantly higher than that of conventional imaging in screening high-risk women. Difficulties can be caused by an atypical manifestation of hereditary breast cancers at both conventional and MR imaging and by contrast material enhancement associated with hormonal stimulation.
比较磁共振(MR)成像与传统成像在筛查高危女性中的应用。
这项前瞻性试验纳入了192名无症状女性和6名有症状女性,这些女性基于个人或家族病史或基因分析,被怀疑或证实携带乳腺癌易感基因。
共发现15例乳腺癌:192名无症状女性中有9例(第一轮筛查中有6例,第二轮筛查中有3例),有症状患者中有6例。对于无症状女性,9例乳腺癌中有4例通过乳腺X线摄影和超声检查(US)联合检测并正确分类;另外2例癌症表现为边界清晰的肿块,被诊断为纤维腺瘤。MR成像能够对所有9例癌症进行正确分类和局部分期。在105名对第一年筛查结果进行验证的无症状女性中,乳腺X线摄影、超声检查和MR成像的敏感性分别为33%、33%(乳腺X线摄影和超声检查联合为44%)和100%;阳性预测值分别为30%、12%和64%。
在筛查高危女性时,MR成像的准确性显著高于传统成像。遗传性乳腺癌在传统成像和MR成像中的非典型表现以及与激素刺激相关的对比剂增强可能会造成困难。