Westerlund M, Sundelin C
Central Unit of Child Health Care, Department of Women's and Children's Health, Unit of Paediatrics, University Hospital, S-751 85 Uppsala, Sweden.
Child Care Health Dev. 2000 Mar;26(2):91-110. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2214.2000.00171.x.
This study evaluates a screening instrument for identification of severe developmental language disability (DLD) in 3-year-old children, which is used as a routine assessment at several child health centres (CHCs) in Sweden. The results are reported in terms of clinical outcome (false- and true-positive rates), kind and extent of DLD, signs of comorbidity and relation between nurses' and parents' observations. More than 60 CHC nurses, all with experience of the screening instrument, assessed in all 2359 3-year-old children (98% of the whole population) by direct observation of their language comprehension, language production and level of co-operation. In addition to the screening parents answered a questionnaire. Children who failed the screening had their hearing assessed and were clinically examined by trained speech and language therapists. Forty-four (34 boys and ten girls) of the 65 referred children were clinically examined. Apart from two false-positive cases most of them were diagnosed as generally and severely language disabled. According to the nurses' observations attention deficit was common among the referred boys, which was later confirmed by the speech therapist in two-thirds of them. Agreement between nurses and parents was poor and only half of the parents were concerned about their child's language development. In the light of this result, continued application of the screening and the use of parent questionnaires is discussed.
本研究评估了一种用于识别3岁儿童严重发育性语言障碍(DLD)的筛查工具,该工具在瑞典的几个儿童健康中心(CHC)用作常规评估。报告结果涉及临床结局(假阳性率和真阳性率)、DLD的类型和程度、共病迹象以及护士与家长观察结果之间的关系。60多名熟悉该筛查工具的CHC护士,通过直接观察2359名3岁儿童(占总人数的98%)的语言理解、语言表达和合作水平进行了评估。除筛查外,家长还回答了一份问卷。筛查未通过的儿童接受了听力评估,并由训练有素的言语和语言治疗师进行临床检查。65名转诊儿童中有44名(34名男孩和10名女孩)接受了临床检查。除了两例假阳性病例外,他们中的大多数被诊断为普遍和严重语言障碍。根据护士的观察,注意力缺陷在转诊男孩中很常见,后来言语治疗师在其中三分之二的男孩中证实了这一点。护士与家长之间的一致性较差,只有一半的家长担心孩子的语言发展。鉴于这一结果,讨论了该筛查的持续应用以及家长问卷的使用。