Marco R A, Sheth D S, Boland P J, Wunder J S, Siegel J A, Healey J H
Department of Surgery, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY 10021, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000 May;82(5):642-51. doi: 10.2106/00004623-200005000-00005.
Metastatic disease of the acetabulum can be painful and disabling. Operative intervention is indicated for patients who fail to respond adequately to nonoperative treatment. We evaluated the functional and oncological outcome of acetabular reconstruction after curettage for the treatment of refractory symptomatic acetabular metastases.
Fifty-five patients with metastatic disease of the acetabulum were treated with operative acetabular reconstruction combined with a total hip replacement. The most common primary tumor was carcinoma of the breast (eighteen patients), followed by carcinoma of the kidney (seven patients) and carcinoma of the prostate (seven patients). Forty (73 percent) of the patients presented with multiple skeletal metastases, and eighteen (33 percent) had associated visceral metastases. Twenty-eight (51 percent) had severe pain requiring continuous use of narcotics, twenty-four (44 percent) had moderate pain requiring periodic use of narcotics, and the remaining three (5 percent) had mild pain requiring use of non-narcotic analgesics. Eighteen (33 percent) of the patients could not walk, twenty-three (42 percent) needed a walker or crutches, twelve (22 percent) used a single cane, and two (4 percent) walked without assistive devices. Intralesional curettage of the tumor was performed in all of the patients. Fifty-four of the hips were reconstructed with a protrusio cup and one, with a hemipelvis endoprosthesis. Large defects were reinforced with cement and pin or screw fixation (the modified Harrington technique), which allowed transmission of weight-bearing forces to the remaining intact pelvis. Thirty-six acetabular reconstructions were performed with antegrade pins or cannulated screws; fifteen, with long retrograde screws; and four, with cement.
The median period of survival was nine months. Patients with visceral metastases had a median period of survival of three months compared with twelve months for patients without visceral metastases (p < 0.001). Patients with breast cancer presented later in the disease process (p < 0.004) and lived longer than did those with other carcinomas (p < 0.004). Forty-five patients were evaluated three months after reconstruction. Thirty-four (76 percent) of them had relief of pain as determined by decreased use of narcotics. Nine of the eighteen patients who could not walk preoperatively regained the ability to walk. Fourteen of the seventeen patients who originally were able to walk in the community retained that ability. Thirty-three patients were available for evaluation at six months. Twenty-five (76 percent) still had relief of pain, and nineteen (58 percent) were able to walk and function in the community. Overall, fourteen (25 percent) of the fifty-five patients had moderate local progression of the disease, and five of these patients had failure of the fixation. Fourteen early complications developed in twelve (22 percent) of the patients. One patient (2 percent) died perioperatively.
Patients who have acetabular metastases that are refractory to radiation and chemotherapy have a short life expectancy. The early, gratifying results of reconstruction validate the role of operative treatment as a short-term palliative procedure. Protrusio acetabular cups presumably compensate for deficiencies of the medial wall, while cement and pin fixation can be used effectively to reconstruct large defects in the acetabular column and dome. The low rate of fixation failure supports the biomechanical principles of the reconstruction. Generally, the reconstructions are sufficiently durable to exceed the life expectancy of the patients.
髋臼转移性疾病可导致疼痛和功能障碍。对于非手术治疗反应欠佳的患者,需进行手术干预。我们评估了刮除术后髋臼重建治疗难治性有症状髋臼转移瘤的功能及肿瘤学结局。
55例髋臼转移性疾病患者接受了髋臼重建手术联合全髋关节置换术。最常见的原发肿瘤为乳腺癌(18例),其次为肾癌(7例)和前列腺癌(7例)。40例(73%)患者存在多发骨转移,18例(33%)伴有内脏转移。28例(51%)有严重疼痛,需持续使用麻醉剂;24例(44%)有中度疼痛,需定期使用麻醉剂;其余3例(5%)有轻度疼痛,需使用非麻醉性镇痛药。18例(33%)患者无法行走,23例(42%)需要助行器或拐杖,12例(22%)使用单拐,2例(4%)无需辅助器械即可行走。所有患者均行肿瘤病灶内刮除术。54例髋关节采用髋臼内陷杯重建,1例采用半骨盆假体重建。大的骨缺损用骨水泥及钢针或螺钉固定(改良哈灵顿技术),使负重力量能够传递至剩余完整骨盆。36例髋臼重建采用顺行钢针或空心螺钉,15例采用长逆行螺钉,4例采用骨水泥。
中位生存期为9个月。有内脏转移的患者中位生存期为3个月,无内脏转移的患者为12个月(p<0.001)。乳腺癌患者在疾病进程中就诊较晚(p<0.004),且生存期比其他癌症患者长(p<0.004)。45例患者在重建后3个月接受评估。其中34例(76%)疼痛缓解,表现为麻醉剂使用减少。术前无法行走的18例患者中有9例恢复了行走能力。最初能够在社区行走的17例患者中有14例保留了该能力。33例患者在6个月时接受评估。25例(76%)仍有疼痛缓解,19例(58%)能够在社区行走并正常生活。总体而言,55例患者中有14例(25%)疾病出现中度局部进展,其中5例固定失败。12例(22%)患者发生了14例早期并发症。1例患者(2%)围手术期死亡。
对放疗和化疗均难治的髋臼转移瘤患者预期寿命较短。重建手术早期令人满意的结果证实了手术治疗作为短期姑息性手术的作用。髋臼内陷杯可能补偿了内侧壁的缺损,而骨水泥和钢针固定可有效重建髋臼柱和髋臼顶的大的骨缺损。固定失败率较低支持了重建的生物力学原理。一般来说,重建的耐久性足以超过患者的预期寿命。