Wyllie E
Department of Neurology, The Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Ohio 44195, USA.
Can J Neurol Sci. 2000 May;27(2):106-10.
Surgery has become an accepted treatment modality for carefully selected adults with intractable focal epilepsy. More recently, increasing numbers of pediatric patients with intractable epilepsy are also being referred for surgical consideration. Key elements of surgical candidacy include medically intractable focal epilepsy, a localized epileptogenic zone, and a low risk for new postoperative neurologic deficits. The most common etiologies of the epilepsies in pediatric surgical candidates are malformation of cortical development and low grade tumor but some patients with childhood onset temporal lobe epilepsy due to hippocampal sclerosis also present for early surgery. Based on results from several recent pediatric surgical series, the chance for favorable seizure outcome after surgery is not adversely affected by young age, with seizure-free postoperative outcome reported for 60% to 65% of infants, 59% to 67% of children, and 69% of adolescents, compared to 64% reported in a large, predominantly adult series. Some subgroups of patients have higher percentages of seizure-free outcome, including those with hippocampal sclerosis or low grade tumor. In addition to seizures, developmental issues are also a major concern in children with intractable epilepsy. Few quantitative data are available, but some anecdotal experience suggests that surgical relief of catastrophic epilepsy may result in resumption of developmental progression after surgery, although the rate of development often remains abnormal. In one series, best developmental outcomes were seen in patients with earliest surgery and highest level of preoperative development. For each patient, the timing of surgery must be carefully considered, based on a full assessment of the relative risks and benefits, derived from a detailed presurgical evaluation.
对于经过精心挑选的患有顽固性局灶性癫痫的成年人,手术已成为一种被认可的治疗方式。最近,越来越多患有顽固性癫痫的儿科患者也被转诊以考虑进行手术。手术候选资格的关键要素包括药物难治性局灶性癫痫、局限性致痫区以及术后出现新的神经功能缺损的低风险。儿科手术候选患者中癫痫最常见的病因是皮质发育畸形和低级别肿瘤,但一些因海马硬化导致儿童期起病的颞叶癫痫患者也会接受早期手术。根据最近几个儿科手术系列的结果,手术时年龄较小并不会对术后良好的癫痫发作结局产生不利影响,婴儿术后无癫痫发作结局的报告比例为60%至65%,儿童为59%至67%,青少年为69%,相比之下,一个以成年人为主的大型系列报告的比例为64%。一些患者亚组无癫痫发作结局的百分比更高,包括那些患有海马硬化或低级别肿瘤的患者。除了癫痫发作,发育问题也是患有顽固性癫痫儿童的一个主要关注点。可用的定量数据很少,但一些轶事经验表明,灾难性癫痫的手术缓解可能会导致术后发育进程恢复,尽管发育速度往往仍不正常。在一个系列中,最早接受手术且术前发育水平最高的患者获得了最佳的发育结局。对于每一位患者,必须在全面评估相对风险和益处的基础上,根据详细的术前评估,仔细考虑手术时机。