Murakawa T, Kosaka M, Mori Y, Fukazawa M, Misaki K
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Kagawa Rosai Hospital.
Nihon Jibiinkoka Gakkai Kaiho. 2000 May;103(5):506-15. doi: 10.3950/jibiinkoka.103.506.
Oxygenation at high pressure (OHP) is thought to be useful, even though regional blood flow is decreased, because increasing dissolved oxygen prevents the death of nerve tissue. In this report, we retrospectively investigated the effect of OHP on sudden deafness.
We reviewed 522 patients treated with OHP at Kagawa Rosai Hospital over a ten-year period (January 1989 to December 1998). We discussed some prognostic factors: comparison between cases which had been treated with OHP previously and those which had not, number of days between onset and beginning of the treatment which included OHP, age, initial averaged five-frequency hearing level, vertigo, tinnitus, complications of OHP, cases of relapse and the time of the onset, which is about season, month and week. OHP was administered at a pressure of 2.5 atmospheres for 80 minutes a day from 10 to 15 times. All patients also received a course of intravenous administration of steroid, vitamin B12, Prostaglandin E1, ATP, and low-molecular dextran.
Overall, complete recovery occurred in 19.7% of the patients, definite improvement in 34.9% (complete recovery included), and slight improvement in 58.1% (definite improvement included). Most of the patients (78.0%) were referred by other hospitals, because our hospital was the only one in the Sikoku area which had a big equipment of OHP. All 161 patients had already been treated in other hospitals over 8 days, but they had shown little improvement after the initial therapy. Of this group, complete recovery after the second course of treatment occurred in 13.0% of the patients, definite improvement in 19.3%, and slight improvement in 39.1%. OHP was thus effective for about 40% of patients who had been unresponsive to the initial therapy. Delay in treatment usually produces poor hearing recovery. There was a significant difference between those patients treated within 14 days and those treated 15 days or more after onset. The improvement rate also decreased with age. The prognosis of patients with vertigo was worse than those without vertigo. Tinnitus had no influence on the prognosis. There were no severe complications during the course of OHP, but otitis media with effusion occurred in 90 patients, and paracentesis was performed for 53 patients.
The treatment of sudden deafness with OHP has been discussed in this report. Important prognostic factors were time between onset and beginning of the treatment which included OHP, age, vertigo, and the initial averaged five-frequency hearing level. We conclude that OHP should be performed within 14 days from onset, and that OHP was able to achieve hearing improvement in many cases unresponsive to the initial therapy if it was performed very early.
高压氧疗(OHP)被认为是有用的,尽管局部血流会减少,因为增加溶解氧可防止神经组织死亡。在本报告中,我们回顾性研究了高压氧疗对突发性耳聋的影响。
我们回顾了在香川罗西医院接受高压氧疗治疗十年(1989年1月至1998年12月)的522例患者。我们讨论了一些预后因素:既往接受过高压氧疗的病例与未接受过高压氧疗的病例之间的比较、发病至开始包括高压氧疗在内的治疗之间的天数、年龄、初始平均五频率听力水平、眩晕、耳鸣、高压氧疗的并发症、复发病例以及发病时间,即季节、月份和星期。高压氧疗在2.5个大气压下每天进行80分钟,共进行10至15次。所有患者还接受了一个疗程的静脉注射类固醇、维生素B12、前列腺素E1、三磷酸腺苷和低分子右旋糖酐治疗。
总体而言,19.7%的患者完全康复,34.9%(包括完全康复)有明显改善,58.1%(包括明显改善)有轻微改善。大多数患者(78.0%)是由其他医院转诊而来,因为我们医院是四国地区唯一拥有大型高压氧疗设备的医院。所有161例患者在其他医院已经接受过8天以上的治疗,但初始治疗后改善甚微。在这组患者中,第二个疗程治疗后完全康复的患者占13.0%,明显改善的患者占19.3%,轻微改善的患者占39.1%。因此,高压氧疗对约40%对初始治疗无反应的患者有效。治疗延迟通常会导致听力恢复不佳。发病后14天内接受治疗的患者与发病后15天或更晚接受治疗的患者之间存在显著差异。改善率也随年龄增长而降低。有眩晕的患者预后比无眩晕的患者差。耳鸣对预后没有影响。高压氧疗过程中没有严重并发症,但90例患者发生了渗出性中耳炎,53例患者进行了穿刺。
本报告讨论了用高压氧疗治疗突发性耳聋的情况。重要的预后因素包括发病至开始包括高压氧疗在内的治疗之间的时间、年龄、眩晕和初始平均五频率听力水平。我们得出结论,高压氧疗应在发病后14天内进行,如果早期进行,高压氧疗能够使许多对初始治疗无反应的病例听力得到改善。