Weber F, Albert U
Dept. of Neurology, Military Hospital Ulm/Donau, Germany.
Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol. 2000 Jun;40(4):231-6.
To determine the diagnostic efficacy of late responses and of magnetic stimulation in the electrodiagnostic evaluation of lumbosacral radiculopathies, 42 patients with acute monoradiculopathies of L5 or S1 were examined. We performed conventional nerve conduction studies, F-wave studies, needle electrode examination (NEE) and magnetic stimulation. The results were compared with a control group of 36 persons. In the patients with weakness, we found a diagnostic sensitivity for NEE of 90% in L5 and of 80% in S1. F-waves had the same sensitivity as NEE in the patients with weakness and were more sensitive in the group of patients without weakness (L5 80%, S1 67%). Magnetic stimulation had a sensitivity of 40% in all groups. There were also abnormalities of NEE and of F-wave studies in the patients with abnormal magnetic stimulation. It is concluded that NEE is the single most effective method in acute LSR and that F-wave studies are able to provide complementary information. Magnetically evoked motor nerve root stimulation was not found of clinically relevant diagnostic value.
为确定迟发反应及磁刺激在腰骶神经根病电诊断评估中的诊断效能,我们对42例L5或S1急性单神经根病患者进行了检查。我们进行了常规神经传导研究、F波研究、针电极检查(NEE)及磁刺激。将结果与36名健康对照者组成的对照组进行比较。在存在肌无力的患者中,我们发现NEE对L5神经根病的诊断敏感性为90%,对S1神经根病为80%。F波在存在肌无力的患者中与NEE具有相同的敏感性,而在无肌无力的患者组中更敏感(L5为80%,S1为67%)。磁刺激在所有组中的敏感性为40%。磁刺激异常的患者中也存在NEE及F波研究异常。结论是,NEE是急性腰骶神经根病最有效的单一方法,F波研究能够提供补充信息。磁诱发运动神经根刺激未发现具有临床相关的诊断价值。