Terheyden H, Maune S, Mertens J, Hilberg O
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Head and Neck Surgery, University of Kiel, D-24105 Kiel, Germany.
J Appl Physiol (1985). 2000 Sep;89(3):1013-21. doi: 10.1152/jappl.2000.89.3.1013.
The aim of the present study was a validation of acoustic rhinometry (AR) by computed tomography (CT). Six healthy subjects were examined by CT and AR. The CT data were processed in a computer program (AutoCAD), and a virtual three-dimensional model of each nasal cavity was constructed. This model permitted an individual prediction of the center line of the sound wave propagation through the air volume of the nasal cavity with the cross-sectional areas oriented perpendicularly to this line. The area-distance curves derived from AR and CT were compared. Linear regression analysis revealed a reasonable agreement of AR and CT in the anterior nose below a mean of 6 cm distance from the nostrils [r = 0.839, P < 0.01, m = 1.123, b = -0.113 (AR = m x CT + b)]. The measuring accuracy using CT as gold standard revealed a mean error at the nasal valve of <0.01 cm(2) (4.52%) and at the nasal isthmus of 0.02 cm(2) (1. 87%). Beyond 6 cm, the correlation decreased (r = 0.419), and overestimation of the true area occurred (>100%). In conclusion, the measurements were reasonably accurate for diagnostic use up to the turbinate head region. Certain factors induce an overestimation of the true areas beyond this region. However, these factors are constant and reproducible in a single subject, and intraindividual comparative measurements are possible beyond the turbinate head region.
本研究的目的是通过计算机断层扫描(CT)验证鼻声反射(AR)。对6名健康受试者进行了CT和AR检查。CT数据在计算机程序(AutoCAD)中进行处理,并构建每个鼻腔的虚拟三维模型。该模型能够单独预测声波通过鼻腔气腔传播的中心线,其横截面与该线垂直。比较了AR和CT得出的面积-距离曲线。线性回归分析显示,在距鼻孔平均距离6 cm以下的鼻前部,AR和CT具有合理的一致性[r = 0.839,P < 0.01,m = 1.123,b = -0.113(AR = m×CT + b)]。以CT作为金标准的测量准确性显示,鼻瓣膜处的平均误差<0.01 cm²(4.52%),鼻峡部的平均误差为0.02 cm²(1.87%)。超过6 cm时,相关性降低(r = 0.419),出现对真实面积的高估(>100%)。总之,在鼻甲头部区域之前,测量对于诊断用途具有合理的准确性。某些因素会导致该区域之外的真实面积被高估。然而,这些因素在单个受试者中是恒定且可重复的,并且在鼻甲头部区域之外进行个体内比较测量是可行的。