Kaiser K A, Johnson K E
Ithaca College, Ithaca, USA.
J Music Ther. 2000 Fall;37(3):222-34. doi: 10.1093/jmt/37.3.222.
The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of an interactive experience on music majors' perceptions of music experiences for deaf students. Twenty-three members of a pre-existing college brass ensemble served as subjects, and a 1-hour interactive concert/presentation for 10 deaf elementary children served as the independent variable. The interactive experience was designed to provide social, musical, and educational interactions between the college musicians and the deaf children. A pretest-posttest design was utilized, and the dependent variable was a questionnaire designed to examine the subjects' perceptions regarding music for deaf students, including how prepared, comfortable, and willing they felt to provide music experiences for deaf students. Results reveal that this single interactive experience had a significant effect on the subjects' perceptions of the value of music in the education of deaf children (p <.05). Although the pretest and posttest scores indicate that the subjects felt apprehensive about their preparedness to work with deaf students, the subjects felt significantly more positive about their preparedness following the interaction (p <.001). An analysis of open comments indicates that the subjects perceived the experience as (a) very positive, (b) increasing their knowledge and perception of music for deaf students, (c) helping them better relate to the deaf population, (d) promoting interest in similar experiences and in gaining more information, and (e) eliciting a feeling that future teachers should have similar experiences. Quotes from the subjects are given, and implications for teacher training/music therapy programs are discussed.
本研究的目的是考察一种互动体验对音乐专业学生关于聋人学生音乐体验认知的影响。一个已有的大学铜管乐团的23名成员作为研究对象,为10名失聪小学生举办的1小时互动音乐会/展示作为自变量。这种互动体验旨在为大学生音乐家和失聪儿童之间提供社交、音乐和教育方面的互动。研究采用了前测-后测设计,因变量是一份问卷,旨在考察研究对象对聋人学生音乐的认知,包括他们在为聋人学生提供音乐体验时的准备程度、舒适度和意愿程度。结果显示,这一单一的互动体验对研究对象关于音乐在聋人儿童教育中的价值的认知产生了显著影响(p<.05)。虽然前测和后测分数表明研究对象对与聋人学生合作的准备情况感到担忧,但在互动之后,他们对自己的准备情况感觉明显更积极(p<.001)。对开放性评论的分析表明,研究对象将这次体验视为(a)非常积极的,(b)增加了他们对聋人学生音乐的知识和认知,(c)帮助他们更好地与聋人群体建立联系,(d)激发了对类似体验和获取更多信息的兴趣,以及(e)引发了一种感觉,即未来的教师应该有类似的体验。文中给出了研究对象的引述,并讨论了对教师培训/音乐治疗项目的启示。